2014년 9월 21일 일요일

THE SACRED BOOKS OF THE EAST 26

THE SACRED BOOKS OF THE EAST 26


difficult and obscure paragraph; but are obliged to quote in the
end the judgment of Kb. Hsi that ' it is vague and intractable, and
not \vorth taking much trouble about.'



44-0 THE Li k1.



BK. XLII.



thus illustrating how the aged should be cherished
and nourished.

When the people knew to honour their elders and
nourish their aged, then at home they could practise
filial piety and fraternal duty. Filial and fraternal
at home and abroad, honouring elders and nourish-
ing the aged, then their education was complete,
and this led to the peace and tranquillity of the
state. What the superior man calls filial piety,
does not require that (every) family should be
visited and its members daily taught ; if (the people)
be assembled at the archery meetings in the dis-
tricts, and taught the usages at the district-drinkings,
their conduct is brought to be filial and fraternal.

9. Confucius said, ' When I look on at the festivity
in the country districts, I know how easily the Royal
way may obtain free course.

10. ' The host in person invites the principal guest
and his attendant, and all the other guests follow
them of themselves. When they arrive outside the
gate, he bows (and welcomes) the chief guest and
his attendant, and all the others enter of themselves.
In this way the distinction between the noble and
the mean is exhibited.

11.' With the interchange of three bows (the host
and guest) arrive at the steps ; and after precedence
has been thrice yielded to him, the guest ascends. In
bowing to him (on the hall), (the host) presents to
him the cup, and receives the cup from him in
return. The usages between them, now declining,
now yielding, the one to the other, are numerous ;
but the attention paid to the assistant is less. As
to the crowd of guests, they ascend, and receive the
cup. Kneeling down they offer some of it in sacri-



BK. xlii. HSIANG YIN Kit t 44 1

fice ; they rise and drink it ; and without pledging
the host in the return-cup, they descend. In this
way the proper distinction is made between the
different parties by the multitude or paucity of the
observances paid to them.

12. ' The musicians enter, ascend the hall, and sing
the three pieces which complete their performance,
after which the host offers to them the cup. The
organists enter, and (below the hall) play three tunes,
which complete their part of the performance, after
which the host offers to them (also) the cup. Then
they sing and play alternately other three pieces and
tunes ; and also thrice again they sing and play-
in concert. When this is finished, the musicians
announce that the music is over, and go out.

' At the same time a person (as instructed by the
host) takes up the horn, and one is appointed to
superintend the drinking, and see that it proceeds
correctly. From this we know how they could be
harmonious and joyful, without being disorderly.

1 3. ' The (principal) guest pledges the host, the
host pledges the attendants, the attendants pledge
all the guests. Young and old pledge one another
according to their age, and the cup circulates on to
the keepers of the vases and the cup-washers. From
this we know how they could practise brotherly
deference to their elders without omitting any one.

14. ' Descending (after this), they take off their
shoes ; ascending again, and taking their seats, they
take their cups without any limit as to number. But
the regulations of the drinking do not allow them to
neglect the duties either of the morning or evening.
When the guests go out, the host bows to each
as he escorts him away. The regulations and



442



THE Li Kt BK. XLII.



forms are observed to the end ; and from this we
know how they could enjoy the feast without turbu-
lence or confusion.

15. 'The distinction between the noble and
mean thus exhibited ; the discrimination in the
multitude or paucity of the observances to different
parties ; the harmony and joy without disorder ; the
brotherly deference to elders without omitting any ;
the happy feasting without turbulence or confusion ; —
the observance of these five things is sufficient to
secure the rectification of the person, and the tran-
quillity of the state. When that one state is
tranquil, all under heaven will be the same. There-
fore I say that when I look on at the festivity in the
country districts, I know how easily the Royal Way
may obtain free course V

16. According to the meaning attached to the
festivity of drinking in the country districts, the
principal guest was made to represent heaven ; the
host, to represent earth ; their attendants respec-
tively to represent the sun and moon ; and the three
head guests (according to the threefold division of
them) to represent the three (great) luminaries.
This was the form which the festivity received on
its institution in antiquity: the presiding idea was
found in heaven and earth ; the regulation of that
was found in the sun and moon ; and the three
luminaries were introduced as a third feature. (The



1 I have supposed that all from paragraph 9 to this is the language
of Confucius, and translated in the present tense as he would speak.
Possibly, however, after par. 9 the compiler of the Book may be
giving his own views of the different parts of the festivity (which
would in that case have to be translated in the past tense), and then
winds up with therefore ' He — Confucius — said,' &c.



BK. XLII. HSIANG YIN KIU I. 443



whole represented) the fundamental principles in the
conduct of government and instruction.

1 7. The dogs were boiled on the eastern side (of
the courtyard 1 );— in reverential acknowledgment of
the fact that the vivifying and expanding power in
nature issues from the east.

The washings took place at the eastern steps,
and the water was kept on the east of the washing-
place ; — in reverential acknowledgment of the fact
that heaven and earth have placed the sea on the
left.

The vessel contained the dark-coloured liquid ; —
teaching the people not to forget the original
practice (at ceremonies).

18. The rule was that the (principal) guest should
face the south. The quarter of the east suggests
the idea of the spring, the name of which (also)
denotes the appearance of insects beginning to
move : — (there is then at work that mysterious)
intelligence which gives birth to all things. The
quarter of the south suggests the idea of the
summer, the name of which (also) denotes what
is great : — what nourishes things, encourages their
growth, and makes them great is benevolence. The
quarter of the west suggests the idea of the autumn,
the name of which also denotes gathering or collect-
ing :— the fruits of the earth are gathered at this
season, suggesting the idea of justice in discrimi-



1 Compare the statement in paragraph 3, that ' the viands come
forth from the room on the east.' Khka. Hsiang-tao says :— ' The
dog is a creature that keeps watch, and is skilful in its selection of
men • — it w ill keep away from any one who is not what he should
be. On this account the ancients at all their festive occasions of
eating and drinking employed it.'



444 THE li K ^-



BK. XLII.



nating and guarding. The quarter of the north
suggests the idea of winter, the name of which
denotes also what is kept within: — and the being
within leads us to think of being stored up. On
this account, when the son of Heaven stands up,
he keeps (the quarter of the life-giving) intelligence
on his left hand, faces (the quarter of) benevolence,
has that of justice on his right hand, and that of
depositing behind him 1 .

19. It was the rule that his attendants should face
the east ; thus (making) the principal guest to be the
chief (party) at the festivity.

1 The .Oien-lung editors say that portions of this paragraph
have been lost, and that other parts are out of their proper place ;
and they suggest the additions and alterations necessary to make
it right. It is not worth while, however, to consider their views.
No alterations will remedy its incurable defects or reverse the
severe judgment passed on it by P. Callery : — ' The method,' he
says, ' by which the author proceeds is exceedingly eccentric, and
partakes at once of the nature of the pun, of allegory, and of
mysticism. He begins by basing his comparisons on the resem-
blance of certain sounds, or the homophony of certain words.
Then he seeks to find in the sense, proper to those words that
are homophonous or nearly so, connexions with the principal word
in the text ; and as those connexions are far from being natural or
simply plausible, he puts his spirit to the torture, and goes to seek
in the mysterious action of nature points of contact of which no
one would think. Thus in the sound khun (3j|v, llf) he finds
a natural analogy between the slow and gradual movement of a
worm without eyes, and the march, equally slow and gradual, of
vegetation in spring; in the sounds hsia and kia. fli, $g)
he finds a direct connexion between greatness and the action
which makes plants become great in summer. So in the same
way with the other sounds which he deals with. To many
Chinese this fashion of reasoning appears to be very profound ;
but, as I think, it is nothing but a childish play on words and
hollow ideas.'



BK. XLII. HSIANG YIN Kit f. 445

It was the rule that the host should be in the
eastern quarter. The eastern quarter suggests the
idea of spring, the name of which (also) denotes the
appearance of insects beginning to move, and (it is
spring) which produces all things. The host makes
the festivity ; that is, he produces all things.

20. The moon, after three days, completes the
period of its dark disk. Three months complete
a season. Therefore in this ceremony precedence
is thrice yielded to the guest, and in establishing
a state three high ministers must be appointed.
That the euests are in three divisions, each with
its head or leader, indicated the fundamental prin-
ciples in the administration of government and
instruction, and was the third great feature of the
ceremony.



BOOK XLIII. SH& 1

OR

THE MEANING OF THE CEREMONY OF ARCHERY 1 .

i. Anciently it was the rule for the feudal lords,
when they would practise archery, first to celebrate
the ceremony of the Banquet, and for the Great officers
and ordinary officers, when they would shoot, first to
celebrate the ceremony of the Drinking in the country
districts. The ceremony of the Banquet served to
illustrate the relation between ruler and subject ;
that of the District-drinking, to illustrate the distinc-
tion between seniors and juniors.

2. The archers, in advancing, retiring, and all
their movements, were required to observe the
rules. With minds correct, and straight carriage
of the body, they were to hold their bows and
arrows skilfully and firmly ; and when they did so,
they might be expected to hit the mark. In this
way (from their archery) their characters could be
seen 1 .

3. To regulate (the discharging of the arrows),
there was, — in the case of the son of Heaven, the
playing of the 3au-yii ; m the case of the feudal
lords, that of the Li-shau ; in the case of the digni-
taries, the Great officers, that of the 3hai-pin ; and
in the case of officers, that of the 3hai-fan 2 .

1 See introductory notice, vol. xxvii, pages 56, 57.

2 Each archer discharged four arrows at the target. According
to the account of the duties of the superintendent of archery in



BK. XLIII.



she i. 447



The 3au-yti 1 is expressive of joy that every office
is (rightly) filled ; the Li-shau is expressive of the joy
at audiences of the court ; the 3hai-pin is expres-
sive of the joy in observing the laws (which have been
learned) ; and the 3hai-fan is expressive of the joy
in being free from all failures in duty. Therefore
the son of Heaven regulated his shooting by keep-
ing in his mind the right feeling of all officers ; a
feudal prince, by keeping in his mind the times of
his appearing before the son of Heaven ; a digni-
tary, being a Great officer, by keeping in his mind
the observing of the laws (which he had learned) ;
and an officer, by keeping in his mind that he must
not fail in the duties of his office.

In this way, when they clearly understood the
meaning of those regulating: measures, and were thus
able to avoid all failure in their services, they were
successful in their undertakings, and their character



the A'au Li (j|^ J^, Book XXX, paragraphs 54-67, especially
57), the 3au-yu was played or sung nine times; the Li-shau
seven times ; and the two other pieces five times. When the king
was shooting therefore, he began to shoot after the fifth perform-
ance, and had all the previous time to prepare himself; a prince
began to shoot after the third performance ; and in the two other
cases there was only the time of one performance for preparation.

1 The 3au-yii is the last piece in the 2nd Book of the first
part of the Book of Poetry ; supposed to celebrate the benevolence
of the king ; here seen in his delight at every office being rightly
filled. The Li-shau, ' Fox's Head,' or ' Wild Cat's Head,' has not
come down to us; — see note 2, page 124. The 3 ha i -pin and
3hai-fan are the fifth and second pieces of the same Book and
same part of the Shih as the 3au-yu. The regulating the dis-
charge of the arrows by the playing of these pieces was part of
the moral discipline to which it was sought to make the archery
subservient.



44§ THE LI A'f.



BK. XLIII.



and conduct were established. When their charac-
ters were established, no such evils as oppression
and disorder occurred ; and when their undertakings
were successful, the states were tranquil and happy.
Hence it is said that ' the archery served to show
the completeness of (the archer's) virtue.'

4. Therefore, anciently, the son of Heaven chose
the feudal lords, the dignitaries who were Great
officers, and the officers, from their skill in archery.
Archery is specially the business of males, and there
were added to it the embellishments of ceremonies
and music. Hence among the things which may
afford the most complete illustration of ceremonies
and music, and the frequent performance of which
may serve to establish virtue and good conduct, there
is nothing equal to archery : and therefore the ancient
kings paid much attention to it.

5. Therefore, anciently, according to the royal
institutes, the feudal princes annually presented the
officers who had charge of their tribute to the son
of Heaven, who made trial of them in the archery-
hall. Those of them whose bodily carriage was in
conformity with the rules, and whose shooting was
in agreement with the music, and who hit the mark
most frequently, were allowed to take part at the
sacrifices. When his officers had frequently that
privilege, their ruler was congratulated ; if they
frequently failed to obtain it, he was reprimanded.
If a prince were frequently so congratulated, he
received an increase to his territory ; if he were
frequently so reprimanded, part of his territory was
taken from him. Hence came the saying, ' The
archers shoot in the interest of their princes.' Thus,
in the states, the rulers and their officers devoted



BK. XLIII.



she {. 449



themselves to archery, and the practice in connexion
with it of the ceremonies and music. But when
rulers and officers practise ceremonies and music,
never has it been known that such practice led to
their banishment or ruin.

6. Hence it is said in the ode (now lost),

' The long-descended lord
Presents your cups of grace.
His chiefs and noble men
Appear, all in their place ;
Small officers and Great,
Not one will keep away.
See them before their prince,
All in their full array.
They feast, and then they shoot,
Happy and praised to boot.'

The lines show how when rulers and their officers
earnestly devoted themselves together to archery,
and the practice in connexion with it of ceremonies
and music, they were happy and got renown. It
was on this account that the son of Heaven insti-
tuted the custom, and the feudal lords diligently
attended to it. This was the way in which the son
of Heaven cherished the princes, and had no need
of weapons of war (in dealing with them) ; it fur-
nished (also) to the princes an instrument with which
they trained themselves to rectitude.

7. (Once), when Confucius was conducting an
archery meeting in a vegetable garden at K'\o-
hsiang, the lookers-on surrounded it like a wall.
When the proceedings reached the point when a
Master of the Horse should be appointed, he
directed 3 ze_m to take his bow and arrows, and go

[28] G g



45°



THE LI Kl. bk. xLirr.



out to introduce those who wished to shoot, and to
say, ' The general of a defeated army, the Great
officer of a ruler-less state, and any one who (has
schemed to be) the successor and heir of another,
will not be allowed to enter, but the rest may all
enter.' On this, one half went away, and the other
half entered.

After this, (wishing to send the cup round among
all the company), he further directed Kung-wang
K/ilu and Hsu Tien to raise the horns of liquor,
and make proclamation. Then Kung-wang K/iiu
raised his horn, and said, 'Are the young and strong
(here) observant of their filial and fraternal duties?
Are the old and men of eighty (here) such as love
propriety, not following licentious customs, and
resolved to maintain their characters to death ? (If
so), they may occupy the position of guests.' On
this, one half (of those who had entered) went away,
and the other half remained.

Hsu Tien next raised his horn, and proclaimed,
' Are you fond of learning without being tired ? are
you fond of the rules of propriety, and unswerving
in your adherence to them ? Do those of you who
are eighty, ninety, or one hundred, expound the way
(of virtue) without confusion or error ? If so, you
can occupy the position of visitors.' Thereupon
hardly any remained 1 .

8. To shoot means to draw out to the end, and
some say to lodge in the exact point. That draw-



1 The authenticity of what is related in this paragraph, which is
not in the expurgated edition of the Li K\, may be doubted. But
however that be, it is evidently intended to be an illustration of
what did, or might, take place at meetings for archery in the country.
•ATio-hsiang is understood to be the name of some place in Lu.



XLIII.



SHE I. 451



ing out to the end means every one unfolding his
own idea ; hence, with the mind even-balanced and
the body correctly poised, (the archer) holds his bow
and arrow skilfully and firmly. When he so holds
them, he will hit the mark. Hence it is said, ' The
father (shoots) at the father-mark ; the son, at the
son-mark ; the ruler, at the ruler-mark ; the subject,
at the subject-mark.' Thus the archer shoots at the
mark of his (ideal) self; and so the Great archery
of the son of Heaven is called shooting at (the mark
of) the feudal prince. ' Shooting at the mark of the
feudal prince' was shooting to prove himself a
prince. He who hit the mark was permitted to be
(that is, retain his rank as) a prince ; he who did not
hit the mark was not permitted to retain his rank as
a prince l .

9. When the son of Heaven was about to sacri-
fice, the rule was that he should celebrate the
archery at the pool, which name suggested the idea
of selecting the officers (by their shooting) 2 . After



1 In this paragraph we have a remarkable instance of that
punning or playing on words or sounds, which Callery has
pointed out as a ' puerility ' in Chinese writers, and of which we
have many examples in the writers of the Han dynastry. The
idea in the paragraph is good, that when one realises the ideal
of what he is, becoming all he ought to be, he may be said to hit
the mark. But to bring out this from the character (%ft), which
is the symbol of shooting with the bow, the author is obliged to give
it two names,— yi (fift = |≫§, drawing out or unwinding the thread
of a cocoon, or clue of silk, to the end) and she (j|^ = -^,
a cottage or booth, a place to lodge in). The latter is the proper
name for the character in the sense of shooting.

2 Here there is another play on names, — 3 eh, in Pekinese Hi
(M)' has the same name, and means 'to choose, select' There were two

Gg 2



45 2 THE Li KI.



BK. XLIII.



the archery at the pool came that in the archery
hall. Those who hit the mark were permitted to
take part in the sacrifice ; and those who failed were
not permitted to do so. (The ruler of those) who did
not receive the permission was reprimanded, and
had part of his territory taken from him. The ruler
of those who were permitted was congratulated, and
received an addition to his territory. The advance-
ment appeared in the rank ; the disapprobation, in
the (loss of) territory.

10. Hence, when a son is born, a bow of mulberry
wood, and six arrows of the wild raspberry plant
(are placed on the left of the door), for the purpose
of shooting at heaven, earth, and the four cardinal
points. Heaven, earth, and the four points denote
the spheres wherein the business of a man lies.
The young man must first give his mind to what
is to be his business, and then he may venture to re-
ceive emolument, that is, the provision for his food.

ii. Archery suggests to us the way of benevo-
lence. (The archer) seeks to be correct in himself,
and then discharges his arrow. If it miss the mark,
he is not angry with the one who has surpassed
himself, but turns round and seeks (for the cause of
failure) in himself 1 . Confucius said, ' The student
of virtue has no contentions. If it be said that he
cannot avoid them, shall this be in archery ? (But)
he bows complaisantly to his competitor, ascends

places for the archery, one called the ^ai Kung, ' Palace or Hall
by the pool,' and the other, She Kung, ' Palace or Hall of Archery,'
which was, says Callery, ' a vast gallery in the royal college.'

1 Compare above, page 307, paragraph 40, where we have ' the
way of the superior man ' instead of ' the way of benevolence, or
perfect virtue.'



BK. XLIII. SHE f.



453



(the hall), descends (again), and exacts the forfeit of
drinking. In his contention, he is still the superior



man V



1 2. Confucius said, ' How difficult it is to shoot !
How difficult it is to listen (to the music) ! To
shoot exactly in harmony with the note (given) by
the music, and to shoot without missing the bull's-
eye on the target : — it is only the archer of superior
virtue who can do this ! How shall a man of
inferior character be able to hit the mark? It is
said in the Book of Poetry (II, viii, ode 6, i),

'"Now shoot," he says, "and show your skill."
The other answers, " Shoot I will,
And hit the mark ; — and when you miss,
Pray you the penal cup to kiss." '

' To pray ' is to ask. The archer seeks to hit that
he may decline the cup. The liquor in the cup is
designed (properly) to nourish the aged, or the sick.
When the archer seeks to hit that he may decline
the cup, that is declining what should serve to
nourish (those that need it).

1 See Confucian Analects, III, vii.



BOOK XLIV. YEN f

OR
THE MEANING OF THE BANQUET 1 .

i. Anciently, among the officers of the kings of
A^au, there was one called the shu-jze. He was
charged with the care of the sons of the feudal lords,
the high dignitaries who were the Great officers, and
(other) officers, — the eldest sons who occupied the
next place to their fathers. He managed (the issuing)
to them of (all) cautions and orders ; superintended
their instruction in all they had to learn and (the art
of self-)government ; arranged them in their different
classes ; and saw that they occupied their correct
positions. If there were any grand solemnity
(being transacted) in the kingdom, he conducted
them — these sons of the state — and placed them
under the eldest son, the heir-apparent, who made
what use of them he thought fit. If any military
operations were being undertaken, he provided for
them their carriages and coats of mail, assembled for
them the companies of a hundred men and of five men
(of which they should have charge), and appointed
their inferior officers, thus training them in the art
of war : — they were not under the jurisdiction of
the minister of War. In all (other) governmental
business of the state, these sons of it were left free,
their fathers' eldest sons, without public occupation,

1 See introductory notice, vol. xxvii, pages 57, 58.



BK. XLIV.



yen I 455



and were made to attend to the cultivation of
virtuous ways. In spring, (the shii-jze) assembled
them in the college ; and in autumn, in the archery
(hall), that he might examine into their proficiency,
and advanced or degraded them accordingly.

2. The meaning of the ceremony of the banquet
at the feudal courts (may be thus described) : — The
ruler stood on the south-east of (his own) steps on
the east, having his face towards the south, fronting
the ministers or dignitaries who were nearest to
him. They and all the (other) Great officers came
forward a little, taking each his proper station.
The ruler's mat is placed at the top of the eastern
steps : — there is the station of the host. The ruler
alone goes up and stands on his mat ; with his face
to the west he stands there by himself: — showing
that no one presumes to place himself on a par
with him.

3. Guests and host having been arranged, accord-
ing to the rules for the ceremony of drinking in the
country districts, (the ruler) makes his chief cook
act for him in presenting (the cup) : — a minister may
not presume to take on himself any usage proper to
the ruler. None of the (three) kung and no high
minister has the place of a guest ; but the Great
officers are among the guests, — because of the
doubts that might arise, and to show the jealousy
(which such great men in that position might
create).

When the euests have entered to the middle of
the courtyard, the ruler descends a step and bows to
them : — thus courteously receiving them.

4. The ruler sends the cup round among the guests
in order ; and when he has given a special cup to



456 the ii kI



BK. XLIV.



any, they all descend, and bow twice, laying at the
same time their heads to the ground; after which
they ascend, and complete their bowing : — thus
showing the observance due from subjects. The
ruler responds to them, for every act of courtesy
must be responded to : — illustrating the observances
due from the ruler and superiors. When ministers
and inferiors do their utmost to perform service for
the state, the ruler must recompense them with rank
and emoluments. Hence all officers and inferiors
endeavour with their utmost strength and ability to
establish their merit, and thus the state is kept in
tranquillity, and the ruler's mind is at rest.

(The principle) that every act of courtesy must
be responded to, showed that rulers do not receive
anything from their inferiors without sufficient
ground for doing so. The ruler must illustrate
the path of rectitude in his conduct of the people ;
and when the people follow that path and do good
service (for the state), then he may take from them
a tenth part (of their revenues). In this way he
has enough, and his subjects do not suffer want.
Thus harmony and affection prevail between high
and low, and they have no mutual dissatisfactions.
Such harmony and rest are the result of the cere-
monial usages. This is the great idea in the
relation between ruler and subject, between high
and low : — hence it is said that the object of the
banquet was to illustrate the idea of justice between
ruler and subject.

5. The mats were arranged so that the dignitaries
of smaller rank occupied the place next (in honour)
to those of higher ; the Great officers, the place next
to the lower dignitaries. The officers and sons of



BK. XLIV.



yen I 457



concubines 1 (also) took their places below in their
regular order. The cup being presented to the
ruler, he begins the general pledging, and offers
the cup to the high dignitaries 2 . They continue the
ceremony, and offer the cup to the Great officers,
who offer it in turn to the (other) officers, and these
finally offer it to the sons of concubines. The
stands and dishes, with the flesh of the animals : \
and the savoury viands, were all proportioned to
the differences of rank in the guests : — and thus the
distinction was shown between the noble and the
mean.

1 This is a common meaning of the phrase shu-jze. We
cannot suppose that there is a reference to the officer so called in
paragraph i . He was of too high a rank to be placed after the
officers, who ranked below the Great officers. Nor can we
suppose that it denotes here ' the sons of the state ' under his charge.

2 The ruler did this by his deputy, the chief cook, who officiated
for him on the occasion. All the different offerings are said to
have been made by him indeed ; but that is not the natural inter-
pretation of the text.

3 Khzn Hao says these were dogs; see above, page 443, para- graph 17.

THE SACRED BOOKS OF THE EAST 25

THE SACRED BOOKS OF THE EAST 25


Virtue is the root ; wealth is the branches. If he
make the root his secondary object, and the branches
his primary object, he will only quarrel with the
people, and teach them rapine. Hence the accu-
mulation of wealth is the way to scatter the people,
and the distribution of his wealth is the way to
collect the people. Hence (also), when his words
go forth contrary to right, they will come back to



BK. XXXIX. TA HSIO. 42 1



him in the same way, and wealth got by improper
ways will take its departure by the same.

27. It is said in the Announcement to the Prince of
Khang (Shu, V, ix, 2, 3), 'The decree (of Heaven)
is not necessarily perpetual.' That is, goodness
obtains the decree, and the want of goodness
loses it.

28. In a Book of Kim it is said 1 , 'The state of
Kith, does not consider (such a toy) to be precious.
Its good men are what it considers to be precious.'

29. Fan, the maternal uncle (of duke Wan of 3in),
said, ' A fugitive (like you) should not account (that)
to be precious. What he should consider precious
is the affection due (even) to his (deceased) parent 2 .'

30. It is said in the Speech of (duke Mu of) AVzin
(Shu, V, xxx, 6, 7), 'Let me have but one minister,
plain and sincere, not possessed of other abilities,
but with a simple, upright, and at the same time
a generous, mind, regarding the talents of others
as if they were his own ; and when he finds accom-
plished and perspicacious men, loving them in his
heart more than his mouth expresses, and really
showing himself able to bear them (and employ
them), — such a minister will be able to preserve my
sons and grandsons, and other benefits (to the state)
may well be expected from him. But if (it be his
character), when he finds men of ability, to be



1 The narratives about Khu, Section II, Article 5, in the ' Nar-
ratives of the States.' The exact characters of the text are not
found in the article, but they might easily arise from what we do
find. An officer of £in is asking Wang-sun Wei, an envoy from
Khu, about a famous girdle of that state. The envoy calls it a
toy, and gives this answer.

2 See vol. xxvii, page 165, paragraph 19.



422 THE L? Kl.



BK. XXXIX.



jealous of them and hate them ; and, when he
finds accomplished and perspicacious men, to oppose
them, and not allow their advancement, showing
himself really not able to bear them, — such a man
will not be able to protect my sons and grandsons,
and black-haired people ; and may he not also be
pronounced dangerous (to the state) ? '

31. It is only the truly virtuous man that can
send away such a man and banish him, driving him
out among the barbarous tribes around, determined
not to dwell with him in the Middle states. This is
in accordance with the saying, ' It is only the truly
virtuous man who can love others or can hate
others.'

32. To see men of worth, and not be able to
raise them to office ; to raise them to office, but not
to do so quickly : — this is treating them with dis-
respect. To see bad men, and not to be able to
remove them ; to remove them, but not to do so to
a distance : — this is weakness.

33. To love those whom men hate, and to hate
those whom men love : — this is to outrage the
natural feeling of men. Calamities are sure to come
on him who does so.

34. Thus we see that the ruler has a great course
to pursue. He must show entire self-devotion and
sincerity to succeed, and by pride and extravagance
he will fail.

35. There is a great course (also) for the produc-
tion of wealth. Let the producers be many, and the
consumers few. Let there be activity in the pro-
duction, and economy in the expenditure. Then
the wealth will always be sufficient.

36. The virtuous (ruler) uses his wealth so as to



BK. xxxix. TA HSIO. 42?



3



make himself more distinguished. The vicious
ruler will accumulate wealth, even though it cost
him his life.

37. Never has there been a case of the superior
loving benevolence, and his inferiors not loving
righteousness. Never has there been a case where
(his inferiors) loved righteousness, and the business
(of the superior) has not reached a happy issue.
Never has there been a case where the wealth
accumulated in the treasuries and arsenals (of such
a ruler and people) did not continue to be his.

38. Mang Hsien-jze * said, ' He who keeps his
team of horses 2 does not look after fowls and pigs.
The family which has its stores of ice 3 does not
keep cattle or sheep. The house which possesses
a hundred chariots 4 should not keep a grasping
minister to gather up all the taxes for it. Than
have such a minister, it would be better to have one
who would rob it of its revenues.' This is in
accordance with the saying, 'In a state gain should
not be considered prosperity ; its prosperity lies in
righteousness/

39. When he who presides over a state or a
family makes his revenues his chief business, he
must be under the influence of some small man.
He may consider him to be good ; but when such a
person is employed in the administration of a state

1 The worthy minister of Lu, mentioned in vol. xxvii, p. 154, et al.
His name was A'ung-sun Mieh. Hsien was his posthumous title.

2 An officer who has just attained to be a Great officer, and
received from the ruler the carriage of distinction.

3 To be used in sacrificing; but, we may suppose, for other
uses as well.

4 A dignitary, possessing an appanage.



424 THE L{ Kt.



BK. XXXIX.



or family, calamities and injuries will befal it to-
gether; and though a good man (may take his
place), he will not be able to remedy the evil. This
illustrates (again) the saying, ' In a state gain should
not be considered prosperity ; its prosperity should
be sought in righteousness.'



BOOK XL. KWAN t

OR
THE MEANING OF THE CEREMONY OF CAPPING 1 .

I. Generally speaking, that which makes man
man is the meaning of his ceremonial usages. The
first indications of that meaning appear in the correct
arrangement of the bodily carriage, the harmonious
adjustment of the countenance, and in the natural
ordering of the speech. When the bodily carriage is
well arranged, the countenance harmoniously ad-
justed, and speech naturally ordered, the meaning of
the ceremonial usages becomes complete, and serves
to render correct the relation between ruler and
subject, to give expression to the affection between
father and son, and to establish harmony between
seniors and juniors. When the relation between
ruler and subject is made correct, affection secured
between father and son, and harmony shown between
seniors and juniors, then the meaning of those usages
is established. Hence after the capping has taken
place, provision is made for every other article of
dress. With the complete provision of the dress,
the bodily carriage becomes (fully) correct, the
harmonious expression of the countenance is made
perfect, and the speech is all conformed to its
purposes. Hence it is said that in capping we have
the first indications of (the meaning of the) cere-
monial usages. It was on this account that the sage

1 See the introductory notice, vol. xxvii, pp. 54, 55.



426 THE Li Kl. BK. XL.

kings of antiquity made so much as they did of the
capping.

2. Anciently, when about to proceed to the
ceremony of capping, they divined for the day by
the stalks, and also for the guests (who should be
present). In this way did they manifest the value
which they attached to capping. Attaching such a
value to it, they made the ceremony very important.
They made the ceremony so important, showing
how they considered it to lie at the foundation of
the state's (prosperity).

3. Hence (also) the capping took place at the top
of the eastern steps, (appropriate to the use of the
Master) ; — to show that the son would (in due time)
take his place. (The father) handed him a (special)
cup in the guests' place. Three caps were used in
the ceremony, each successive one more honourable,
and giving the more importance to his coming of
age. When the capping was over, he received the
name of his maturity. So was it shown that he was
now a full-grown man 1 .

4. He presented himself before his mother, and
his mother bowed to him ; he did the same before
his brothers and cousins, and they bowed to him : —
he was a man grown, and so they exchanged
courtesies with him. In the dark-coloured cap,
and the dark-coloured square-cut robes, he put
down his gift of introduction before the ruler, and
then proceeded with the proper gifts to present him-
self to the high ministers and Great officers, and to
the old gentlemen of the country : — appearing before
them as a man grown.

1 Compare paragraph 2 on pages 437, 438, vol. xxvii.



BK. XL. KWAN 1. 427



5. Treating him (now) as a grown-up man, they
would require from him all the observances of a
full-grown man. Doing so, they would require from
him the performance of all the duties of a son, a
younger brother, a subject, and a junior. But when
these four duties or services were required from him,
was it not right that the ceremony by which he
was placed in such a position should be considered
important ?

6. Thus when the discharge of filial and fraternal
duties, of loyal service, and of deferential submission
was established, he could indeed be regarded as a
(full-grown) man. When he could be regarded as
such, he could be employed to govern other men.
It was on this account that the sage kings attached
such an importance to the ceremony, and therefore
it was said, that in capping we have the introduction
to all the ceremonial usages, and that it is the most
important of the festive services.

Therefore the ancients considered the capping as
so important. Considering it so important, they
performed it in the ancestral temple. They did so,
to do honour to so important a service. Feeling
that it was to be honoured so, they did not dare to
take the responsibility of its performance on them-
selves. Not daring themselves to take the respon-
sibility of it, they therefore humbled themselves, and
gave honour in doing so to their forefathers.



BOOK XLI. HWAN !

OR
THE MEANING OF THE MARRIAGE CEREMONY 1 .

I. The ceremony of marriage was intended to be
a bond of love between two (families of different)
surnames, with a view, in its retrospective character,
to secure the services in the ancestral temple, and in
its prospective character, to secure the continuance
of the family line. Therefore the superior men,
(the ancient rulers), set a great value upon it.
Hence, in regard to the various (introductory) cere-
monies, — the proposal with its accompanying gift 2 ;
the inquiries about the (lady's) name ; the intimation
of the approving divination 3 ; the receiving the
special offerings 4 ; and the request to fix the day 5 : —
these all were received by the principal party (on the
lady's side), as he rested on his mat or leaning-stool
in the ancestral temple. (When they arrived), he
met the messenger, and greeted him outside the
gate, giving place to him as he entered, after which
they ascended to the hall. Thus were the instruc-

1 See the introductory notice, vol. xxvii, page 55.

2 This gift was always a goose ; into the reasons for which it is
not necessary to enter.

3 The gentleman's family had divined on the proposal.

4 These were various.

6 The lady's family fixed this. The first proposal was made,
and perhaps those which followed also, by that important functionary
in Chinese life, 'the go-between,' or a friend acting in that capacity.



BK. XLI. HWAN I. 429

tions received in the ancestral temple 1 , and in this
way was the ceremony respected, and watched over,
while its importance was exhibited and care taken
that all its details should be correct.

2. The father gave himself the special cup 2 to his
son, and ordered him to go and meet the bride ; it
being proper that the male should take the first step
(in all the arrangements). The son, having received
the order, proceeded to meet his bride. Her father,
who had been resting on his mat and leaning-stool
in the temple, met him outside the gate and received
him with a bow, and then the son-in-law entered,
carrying a wild goose. After the (customary) bows
and yieldings of precedence, they went up to the hall,
when the bridegroom bowed twice and put down the
wild goose. Then and in this way he received the
bride from her parents.

After this they went down, and he went out and
took the reins of the horses of her carriage, which
he drove for three revolutions of the wheels, having
handed the strap to assist her in mounting. He
then went before, and waited outside his gate. When
she arrived, he bowed to her as she entered. They
ate together of the same animal, and joined in
sipping from the cups made of the same melon 3 ;



1 Thus a religious sanction entered into the idea of marriage.

2 The same cup that is mentioned in the last chapter, paragraph
3 ; the son received it and gave no cup to the father in return.
This was its speciality. In the capping ceremonies it was given
' in the guests' place ; ' in those of marriage, in the son's chamber.

3 Once when I was permitted to witness this part of a marriage
ceremony, the bridegroom raised his half of the melon, with the
spirit in it, to the bride's lips, and she raised her half to his. Each
sipped a little of the spirit.



43° TH E LI Kl. BK. XLI.

thus showing that they now formed one body, were
of equal rank, and pledged to mutual affection.

3. The respect, the caution, the importance, the
attention to secure correctness in all the details, and
then (the pledge of) mutual affection, — these were
the great points in the ceremony, and served to
establish the distinction to be observed between man
and woman, and the righteousness to be maintained
between husband and wife. From the distinction
between man and woman came the righteousness
between husband and wife. From that righteous-
ness came the affection between father and son ;
and from that affection, the rectitude between ruler
and minister. Whence it is said, ' The ceremony
of marriage is the root of the other ceremonial
observances.'

4. Ceremonies (might be said to) commence with
the capping; to have their root in marriage ; to be most
important in the rites of mourning and sacrifice ; to
confer the greatest honour in audiences at the royal
court and in the interchange of visits at the feudal
courts ; and to be most promotive of harmony in
the country festivals and celebrations of archery.
These were the greatest occasions of ceremony, and
the principal points in them.

5. Rising early (the morning after marriage), the
young wife washed her head and bathed her per-
son, and waited to be presented (to her husband's
parents), which was done by the directrix, as soon
as it was bright day. She appeared before them,
bearing a basket with dates, chestnuts, and slices of
dried spiced meat. The directrix set before her a
cup of sweet liquor, and she offered in sacrifice some
of the dried meat and also of the liquor, thus



BK. XLT.



HWAN I. 431



performing the ceremony which declared her their
son's wife 1 ,

6. The father and mother-in-law then entered
their apartment, where she set before them a single
dressed pig, — thus showing the obedient duty of
(their son's) wife \

7. Next day, the parents united in entertaining
the young wife, and when the ceremonies of their
severally pledging her in a single cup, and her
pledging them in return, had been performed, they
descended by the steps on the west, and she by
those on the east, — thus showing that she would
take the mother's place in the family 1 .

8. Thus the ceremony establishing the young wife
in her position; (followed by) that showing her
obedient service (of her husband's parents) ; and
both succeeded by that showing how she now
occupied the position of continuing the family line: —
all served to impress her with a sense of the defer-
ential duty proper to her. When she was thus
deferential, she was obedient to her parents-in-law,
and harmonious with all the occupants of the
women's apartments; she was the fitting partner
of her husband, and could carry on all the work in
silk and linen, making cloth and silken fabrics, and
maintaining a watchful care over the various stores
and depositories (of the household).

9. In this way when the deferential obedience of
the wife was complete, the internal harmony was

1 The details of the various usages briefly described in these
paragraphs are to be found in the 4th Book of the 1 Li, the 2nd
of those on the scholar's marriage ceremonies: paragraphs 1-10;
1 1-17 ; 18-20. There were differences in the ceremonies according
to the rank of the parties ; but all agreed in their general character.



432 THE LI k1.



BK. XLI.



J



secured ; and when the internal harmony was
secured, the long continuance of the family could be
calculated on. Therefore the ancient kings attached
such importance (to the marriage ceremonies).

10. Therefore, anciently, for three months before
the marriage of a young lady, if the temple of the
high ancestor (of her surname) were still standing
(and she had admission to it), she was taught in it,
as the public hall (of the members of her surname); if
it were no longer standing (for her), she was taught
in the public hall of the Head of that branch of the
surname to which she belonged ; — she was taught
there the virtue, the speech, the carriage, and the
work of a wife. When the teaching was accom-
plished, she offered a sacrifice (to the ancestor), using
fish for the victim, and soups made of duckweed and
pondweed. So was she trained to the obedience of
a wife 1 .

ii. Anciently, the queen of the son of Heaven
divided the harem into six palace-halls, (occupied)
by the 3 ladies called fu-^an, the 9 pin, the 27 shih-
fu, and the 81 yu-k/ii. These were instructed in
the domestic and private rule which should prevail
throughout the kingdom, and how the deferential
obedience of the wife should be illustrated ; and
thus internal harmony was everywhere secured, and
families were regulated. (In the same way) the son
of Heaven established six official departments, in



1 There is supposed to be an allusion to this custom in the Shih,
I, ii, 4, beginning,

' She gathers fast the large duckweed,

From valley stream that southward flows;
And for the pondweed to the pools
Left on the plains by floods she goes.'



BK. XLI.



hwan i. 433



which were distributed the 3 kung, the 9 k/nng,
the 27 ta fu, and the 81 sze of the highest grade.
These were instructed in all that concerned the
public and external government of the kingdom, and
how the lessons for the man should be illustrated ;
and thus harmony was secured in all external affairs,
and the states were properly governed.

It is therefore said, ' From the son of Heaven
there were learned the lessons for men ; and from
the queen, the obedience proper to women.' The
son of Heaven directed the course to be pursued by
the masculine energies, and the queen regulated the
virtues to be cultivated by the feminine receptivities.
The son of Heaven guided in all that affected the
external administration (of affairs) ; and the queen,
in all that concerned the internal regulation (of the
family). The teachings (of the one) and the obe-
dience (inculcated by the other) perfected the
manners and ways (of the people) ; abroad and at
home harmony and natural order prevailed ; the
states and the families were ruled according to
their requirements : — this was what is called ' the
condition of complete virtue.'

12. Therefore when the lessons for men are not
cultivated, the masculine phenomena in nature do
not proceed regularly ; — as seen in the heavens, we
have the sun eclipsed. When the obedience proper
to women is not cultivated, the feminine phenomena
in nature do not proceed regularly; — as seen in the
heavens, we have the moon eclipsed. Hence on an
eclipse of the sun, the son of Heaven put on plain
white robes, and proceeded to repair what was
wrong in the duties of the six official departments,
purifying everything that belonged to the masculine

[28] F f



434



THE L$ kL bk. xli.



sphere throughout the kingdom ; and on an eclipse
of the moon, the queen dressed herself in plain
white robes, and proceeded to repair what was
wrong in the duties of the six palace-halls, purifying
everything that belonged to the feminine sphere
throughout the kingdom. The son of Heaven is to
the queen what the sun is to the moon, or the
masculine energy of nature to the feminine. They
are necessary to each other, and by their interde-
pendence they fulfil their functions.

13. The son of Heaven attends to the lessons for
men ; — that is the function of the father. The queen
attends to the obedience proper to women ; — that is
the function of the mother. Therefore it is said,
1 The son of Heaven and the queen are (to the
people) what father and mother are.' Hence for
him who is the Heaven(-appointed) king they wear
the sackcloth with the jagged edges, — as for a father;
and for the queen they wear the sackcloth with the
even edges, — as for a mother.






BOOK XLII. HSIANG YIN ATl) t

OR

THE MEANING OF THE DRINKING FESTIVITY IN

THE DISTRICTS 1 .

i. The meaning of the drinking in the country
districts may be thus described : — The president on
the occasion bows to the (coming) guest as he
receives him outside the college gate. They enter
and thrice salute each other till they come to the
steps. There each thrice yields the precedence to
the other, and then they ascend. In this way they
carry to the utmost their mutual demonstrations of
honour and humility. (The host) washes his hands,
rinses the cup, and raises it, — to give the highest
idea of purity. They bow on the guest's arrival ;
they bow as (the cup) is washed; they bow when
the cup is received, and when it is presented (in
return) ; they bow when the drinking it is over : —
in this way carrying to the utmost their mutual
respect.

2. Such giving of honour, such humility, such
purity, and such respect belonged to the intercourse
of superior men with others. When they gave
honour and showed humility, no contentions arose.
When they maintained purity and respect, no in-
difference or rudeness arose. When there was no
rudeness or contention, quarrels and disputations
were kept at a distance. When men did not quarrel

1 See the introductory notice, vol. xxvii, page 56.

F f 2



436 THE LI JCI. BK. XLII.

nor dispute, there came no evils of violence or
disorder. It was thus that superior men escaped
suffering calamity from other men ; and therefore
the sages instituted the observances in this ceremony
to secure such a result.

3. The chief of the district with the accomplished
and virtuous men belonging to it had the vessel of
liquor placed between the room (on the east), and
the door (leading to the apartments on the west),
host and guests sharing it between them. The
vessel contained the dark-coloured liquor (of pure
water) ; — showing the value they attached to its sim-
plicity. The viands came forth from the room on
the east ; — being supplied by the host. All washing
took place (in the courtyard) opposite the eastern
wing ; — showing how the host purified himself and
made himself ready to serve the guests.

4. The (principal) guest and the host represented
heaven and earth ; the attendants of the guest and
host respectively represented the forces inherent in
nature in their contracting and expanding operations;
the three (heads of the) guests (in their threefold
division) represented the three (great) luminaries ;
the precedence thrice yielded (to the guest) repre-
sented the three days when the moon is invisible till
it begins to reappear ; the seating of the parties
present (all round or) on the four sides represented
the four seasons \

1 P. Gallery says: — 'There were at this ceremony, 1. the chief
and his assistant; 2. the principal guest who was supposed to
represent all the other guests, and who also had his assistant ;
3. three guests who formed a second category ; 4. finally, the
crowd of guests, a number not fixed, to whom no honour was paid
directly, since they were held to receive all the honours rendered to



BK. XLII. HSIANG YIN Kit f. 437

5. The snell and icy wind (that blows between)
heaven and earth begins in the south-west and
is strongest in the north-west. This is the wind
that represents the most commanding severity of
heaven and earth ; — the wind of their righteous
justice. The warm and genial wind (that blows
between) heaven and earth begins in the north-east
and is strongest in the south-east. This is the wind
that represents the abundant virtue of heaven and
earth ; — the wind of their benevolence. The host,
wishing to do honour to his guest, assigns him his
seat on the north-west, and that of his attendant on
the south-west, that he may there (most conveniently)
assist him. The guest (represents) the treatment of
others according to justice, and therefore his seat is

the principal guest.' A7jan Hao quotes an opinion that the prin-
cipal guest was made to represent heaven, to do him the greater
honour ; and the host to represent the earth, because he was the
entertainer and nourisher; and that their assistants represented
the yin and yang, because they assisted their principals as these
energies in nature assist heaven and earth.

On ' the three Luminaries,' Callery says : — ' Ordinarily the name
of " the three Luminaries " belongs to the sun, the moon, and the
stars, but par. 16 below does not allow us to take it so here.
The commentators say that we are to understand the three most
brilliant constellations in the firmament, which they call Hsin,
Fa, and ~Po-A/ia.n, corresponding, I believe, in part to Orion,
Scorpio, and Argo or the Ship.' So also A7?an Hao's authority.
Hsin is generally understood to be Scorpio (Antares, c. 3584 and 3587); Fa to be v Orion; and Vo-k/ian to be the
north polar star.

On the ' thrice-yielded precedence to the guest,' Callery says : —
' The comparison is far-fetched ; it is intended to say that as the
moon would not receive light if the sun did not accord it, so the
guest would not receive such honours if the host did not render
them.' So the commentators certainly try to explain it.



438 THE Li Kl.



BK. XLII.



on the north-west ; the host (represents) the treat-
ment of others according to benevolence and a genial
kindness, and therefore his seat is on the south-
east, and his attendant is seated on the north-east,
that he may there (most conveniently) assist him *.

6. That intercourse according to benevolence and
righteousness being: established, so as to show the
respective duties of host and guest, and the number
of stands and dishes being properly fixed ; — all this
must be the result of sage intelligence. That
intelligence established the arrangements, and each
one being carried through with respect, it became
a ceremonial usage. That usage proceeding to mark
and embody the distinction between old and young,
it became a virtue. Virtue is that which is the
characteristic of the person. Therefore we have
the saying, ' In the learning of antiquity, the
methods by which they pursued the course adopted
were intended to put men in possession of their
proper virtue.' On this account the sages employed
their powers (on its lessons) 2 .



1 P. Callery observes on this paragraph : — ' The meteorological
observations on which these statements rest must have been made
very long ago in the interior of the country, there where the winds
come under the influence of the icy plains of Tartary and the high
mountains which separate China from Thibet ; for on the sea-
coasts of China, exactly the contrary has place. During the winter
the north-east monsoon prevails, varying sometimes to the north
and sometimes to the east, rarely to the north-west ; while during
the heats of summer the wind blows from the south-west, bending
a little towards the south or towards the east, according as the
monsoon is in the period of its increase or decline. It is generally
in the course of this monsoon that there takes place the terrible
storms known by the name of typhoons.'

2 The K/iien-\\mg editors do their best to elucidate this



BK. XLIT. HSIANG YIN Kit f. 439



7. When (the guest) offers in sacrifice some of the
things that have been set before him, and some
of the liquor, he showed how he respected (the host)
for his courtesy ; when he proceeded to take some
of the lungs in his teeth, he thereby tasted (the
host's) courtesy ; when he then sipped some of the
liquor, that was his last step in acknowledgment
thereof. This last act was done at the end of his
mat, showing that the mat was spread straight
before him, not only for the purpose of eating and
drinking, but also for the performance of the
(proper) rites. In this was shown how it was the
ceremony that was valued, while the wealth was
made little account of. Finally, when the host filled
their cups from the horn, they drained them at the
top of the western steps ; — showing how the mat
was set not (merely) for the purpose of eating and
drinking, and how the idea was that of giving to the
ceremony the first place, and to wealth the last.
But when the ceremony has the first place, and
wealth the last, the people become respectful and
yielding, and are not contentious with one another.

8. At the ceremony of drinking in the country
districts, those who were sixty years old sat, and
those who were (only fifty) stood, and were in
waiting to receive any orders and perform any
services ; — thus illustrating the honour which should
be paid to elders.

Before those who were sixty, three dishes were
placed ; before those of seventy, four ; before those
of eighty, five; before those of ninety, six: —

THE SACRED BOOKS OF THE EAST 24

THE SACRED BOOKS OF THE EAST 24


ready for action: — such are his preparations and
precautions for the future.

6. ' The scholar does not consider gold and jade
to be precious treasures, but leal-heartedness and
good faith ; he does not desire lands and territory,
but considers the establishment of righteousness as
his domain ; he does not desire a great accumulation
of wealth, but looks on many accomplishments as
his riches ; it is difficult to win him, but easy to pay
him ; it is easy to pay him, but difficult to retain him.
As he will not show himself when the time is not
proper for him to do so, is it not difficult to win him ?
As he will have no fellowship with what is not
righteous, is it not difficult to retain him ? As he
must first do the work, and then take the pay, is it
not easy to pay him ? — such are the conditions of his
close association with others.

7. ' Though there may be offered to the scholar
valuable articles and wealth, and though it be tried
to enervate him with delights and pleasures, he sees
those advantages without doing anything contrary to
his sense of righteousness; though a multitude may
attempt to force him (from his standpoint), and his
way be stopped by force of arms, he will look death
in the face without changing the principles (which)
he maintains ; (he would face) birds and beasts of
prey with their talons and wings, without regard to
their fierceness ; he would undertake to raise the
heaviest tripod, without regard to his strength ; he
has no occasion to regret what he has done in the
past, nor to make preparations for what may come
to him in the future ; he does not repeat any error
of speech ; any rumours against him he does not
pursue up to their source ; he does not allow his



A.



EK. xxxviii. ZV HSING. 405



dignity to be interrupted ; he does not dread to
practise (beforehand) the counsels (which he gives): —
such are the things in which he stands out and
apart from other men.

8. ' With the scholar friendly relations may be
cultivated, but no attempt must be made to constrain
him ; near association with him can be sought, but
cannot be forced on him ; he may be killed, but he
cannot be disgraced ; in his dwelling he will not be
extravagant ; in his eating and drinking he will not
be luxurious ; he may be gently admonished of his
errors and failings, but he should not have them
enumerated to him to his face : — such is his boldness
and determination.

9. ' The scholar considers leal-heartedness and
good faith to be his coat-of-mail and helmet ; pro-
priety and righteousness to be his shield and
buckler ; he walks along, bearing aloft over his head
benevolence ; he dwells, holding righteousness in his
arms before him ; the government may be violently
oppressive, but he does not change his course : —
such is the way in which he maintains himself.

10. ' The scholar may have a house in (only)
a mau of ground, — a (poor) dwelling each of whose
(surrounding) walls is (only) ten paces long, with an
outer door of thorns and bamboos, and openings in
the wall, long and pointed ; within, the inner door
stopped up by brushwood, and little round windows
like the mouth of a jar 1 ; the inmates may have to



1 This is a picture of squalid poverty, in which it is not easy to
understand all the details without a discussion of the force of the
Chinese characters, on which it is impossible to enter here. With all
the discussion which they have received from the critics, there are
still difficulties in interpreting the paragraph.



406 THE LI EI. bk. xxxvm.

exchange garments when they go out ; they may
have to make one day's food serve for two days ; if
the ruler respond to him, he does not dare to have
any hesitation (in accepting office) ; if he do not
respond, he does not have recourse to flattery : —
such is he in the matter of taking office, (however
small).

ii. 'The scholar lives and has his associations
with men of the present day, but the men of an-
tiquity are the subjects of his study. Following
their (principles and example) in the present age, he
will become a pattern in future ages. If it should
be that his own age does not understand and en-
courage him, that those above him do not bring him,
and those below him do not push him, forward, or
even that calumniators and flatterers band together
to put him in danger, his person may be placed in
peril, but his aim cannot be taken from him. Though
danger may threaten him in his undertakings and
wherever he is, he will still pursue his aim, and
never forget the afflictions of the people, (which he
would relieve) : — such is the anxiety which he
cherishes.

12. 'The scholar learns extensively, but never
allows his researches to come to an end ; he does
what he does with all his might, but is never weary;
he may be living unnoticed, but does not give way to
licentiousness ; he may be having free course in his
acknowledged position, but is not hampered (by it) ;
in his practice of ceremonial usages he shows the
value which he sets on a natural ease ; in the excel-
lence of his leal-heartedness and good faith, he acts
under the law of a benignant playfulness ; he shows
his fond regard for men of virtue and ability, and yet



BK. xxxvin. ZU HSING. 407



is forbearing and kind to all ; he (is like a potter who)
breaks his square (mould), and his tiles are found
to fit together : — such is the largeness and generosity
of his spirit.

13. 'The scholar recommends members of his
own family (to public employment), without shrinking
from doing so, because of their kinship, and pro-
poses others beyond it, without regard to their being
at enmity with him ; he estimates men's merits, and
takes into consideration all their services, selecting
those of virtue and ability, and putting them for-
ward, without expecting any recompense from them ;
the ruler thus gets what he wishes, and if benefit
results to the state, the scholar does not seek riches
or honours for himself: — such is he in promoting
the employment of the worthy and bringing forward
the able.

14. 'The scholar when he hears what is good,
tells it to (his friends), and when he sees what is
good, shows it to them ; in the view of rank
and position, he gives the precedence to them over
himself; if they encounter calamities and hardships,
he is prepared to die with them ; if they are long
(in getting advancement), he waits for them; if they
are far off, he brings them together with himself : —
such is he in the employment and promotion of his
friends.

15. ' The scholar keeps his person free from stain,
and continually bathes (and refreshes) his virtue ; he
sets forth what he has to say (to his superior by way of
admonition), but remains himself in the back-ground,
trying thus quietly to correct him ; if his superior
do not acknowledge (his advice), he more proudly
and clearly makes his views known, but still does



408 THE Li kI.



bk. XXXVIII.



not press them urgently ; he does not go among those
who are low to make himself out to be high, nor
place himself among those who have little (wisdom)
to make himself out to have much ; in a time of
good government, he does not think little (of what
he himself can do); in a time of disorder, he does
not allow his course to be obstructed ; he does not
(hastily) agree with those who think like himself,
nor condemn those who think differently : — so does
he stand out alone among others and take his own
solitary course.

1 6. ' The scholar sometimes will not take the hiph
office of being a minister of the son of Heaven, nor
the lower office of serving the prince of a state ; he
is watchful over himself in his retirement, and
values a generous enlargement of mind, while at the
same time he is bold and resolute in his intercourse
with others ; he learns extensively that he may
know whatever should be done ; he makes himself
acquainted with elegant accomplishments, and thus
smoothes and polishes all his corners and angles ;
although the offer were made to share a state with
him, it would be no more to him than the small
weights of a balance ; he will not take a ministry,
he will not take an office : — such are the rules and
conduct he prescribes to himself.

1 7. ' The scholar has those with whom he agrees
in aim, and pursues the same objects, with whom he
cultivates the same course, and that by the same
methods; when they stand on the same level with
him, he rejoices in them ; if their standing be below
his, he does not tire of them ; if for long he has
not seen them, and hears rumours to their prejudice,
he does not believe them ; his actions are rooted in



BK. XXXVIII.



zij HSING. 409



correctness, and his standing is in what is right 1 ; if
they proceed in the same direction with him, he
goes forward with them, if not in the same direction,
he withdraws from them : — so is he in his inter-
course with his friends.

18. 'Gentleness and goodness are the roots of
humanity ; respect and attention are the ground on
which it stands ; generosity and large-mindedness
are the manifestation of it ; humility and courtesy
are the ability of it ; the rules of ceremony are the
demonstration of it ; speech is the ornament of it ;
singing and music are the harmony of it ; sharing
and distribution are the giving of it. The scholar
possesses all these qualities in union and has them,
and still he will not venture to claim a perfect
humanity on account of them : — such is the honour
(he feels for its ideal), and the humility (with which)
he declines it (for himself).

19. 'The scholar is not cast down, or cut from
his root, by poverty and mean condition ; he is not
elated or exhausted by riches and noble condition ;
he feels no disgrace that rulers and kings (may try
to inflict) ; he is above the bonds that elders and
superiors (may try to impose) ; and superior officers
cannot distress him. Hence he is styled a scholar.
Those to whom the multitude now-a-days give that
name have no title to it, and they constantly employ
it to one another as a term of reproach.'

When Confucius came (from his wanderings to
Lu) to his own house, duke Ai gave him a (public)
lodging-. When the duke heard these words, he
became more sincere in his speech, and more



1 I suspect there is here some error in the text.



4-IO THE LI k1.



BK. XXXVIII.



righteous in his conduct. He said, ' To the end of
my days I will not presume to make a jest of the
name of scholar 1 .'



1 It is doubtful whether any of this paragraph should be ascribed
to Confucius, even in the sense in which we receive the preceding
paragraphs as from him. Evidently the latter half of it is a note
by the compiler to show the effect which the long discourse had on
duke Ai.



BOOK XXXIX. TA HSIO

OR
THE GREAT LEARNING 1 .

i. What the Great Learning teaches, is to illus-
trate illustrious virtue ; to love the people 2 ; and
to rest in the highest excellence.

The point where to rest being known, the object
of pursuit is then determined ; and, that being
determined, a calm unperturbedness may be at-
tained to. To that calmness there will succeed a
tranquil repose. In that repose there will be careful
deliberation, and that deliberation will be followed
by the attainment (of the desired end).

Thino-s have their root and their branches; affairs
have their end and their beginning. To know what
is first and what is last will lead near to what is
taught (in the Great Learning).

2. The ancients who wished to illustrate illus-
trious virtue throughout the kingdom, first ordered
well their states. Wishing to order well their
states, they first regulated their families. Wishing
to regulate their families, they first cultivated their
persons. Wishing to cultivate their persons, they



1 See the introductory notice, vol xxvii, pp. 53, 54.

2 The text of the Ta Hsio, since the labours of Ku Hsi upon it,
reads here— 'to renovate/ instead of 'to love,' the people. Ku
adopted the alteration from Po-shun, called also Ming-tao, one of his
' masters/ the two brothers ATAang; but there is really no authority
for it.



412 THE L? El.



BK. XXXIX.



first rectified their hearts. Wishing to rectify their
hearts, they first sought to be sincere in their
thoughts. Wishing to be sincere in their thoughts,
they first extended to the utmost their knowledge.

3. The extension of knowledge is by the investi-
gation of things \

4. Things being investigated, their knowledge
became complete. Their knowledge being com-
plete, their thoughts were sincere. Their thoughts
being sincere, their hearts were then rectified.
Their hearts being rectified, their persons were
cultivated. Their persons being cultivated, their
families were regulated. Their families being regu-
lated, their states were rightly governed. Their
states being rightly governed, the whole kingdom
was made tranquil and happy.

From the son of Heaven down to the multitudes
of the people, all considered the cultivation of the
person to be the root (of everything besides). It
cannot be, when the root is neglected, that what
should spring from it will be well ordered. It never
has been the case that what was of great importance
has been slightly cared for, and at the same time
what was of slight importance has been greatly
cared for 2 .



3 There is great difficulty in determining the meaning of this
short sentence. What A'ang and Khung Ying-ta say on it is
unsatisfactory. Ku. introduces a long paragraph explaining it from
his master J£//ang; — see Chinese Classics, vol. i, pp. 229, 239.

2 Here ends the first chapter of the Book according to the
arrangement of Kh Hsi. He says that it is ' the words of Con-
fucius, handed down by 3ang-^ze,' all the rest being the com-
mentary of 3ang-$ze, recorded by his disciples. The sentiments
in this chapter are not unworthy of Confucius ; but there is no



bk. xxxix. TA HSIO. 413

This is called ' knowing the root/ this is called
'the perfection of knowledge.'

5. What is called 'making the thoughts sincere'
is the allowing no self-deception ; — as when we hate
a bad smell and love what is beautiful, naturally
and without constraint. Therefore the superior man
must be watchful over himself when he is alone.
There is no evil to which the small man, dwelling
retired, will not proceed ; but when he sees a
superior man, he tries to disguise himself, conceal-
ing his evil, and displaying what is good. The
other beholds him as if he saw his heart and reins ; —
of what use (is his disguise) ? This is an instance
of the saying, * What truly is within will be mani-
fested without.' Therefore the superior man must
be watchful over himself when he is alone.

6. 3angize said, ' What ten eyes behold, what
ten hands point to, is to be regarded with reverence 1 .
(As) riches adorn a house, so virtue adorns the
person. When the mind becomes enlarged, the
body appears at ease. Therefore the superior man
is sure to make his thoughts sincere.

7. It is said in the Book of Poetry (I, v, ode 1, 1),
' How rich the clumps of green bamboo,

Around each cove of Kh\ !



evidence that they really proceeded from him, nor of the other
assertions of Ku. See what is said on the subject in the intro-
ductory notice.

1 This saying is from 3ang-jze ; but standing as it does alone
and apart, it gives no sanction to the view that the first chapter was
handed down by him, or the rest of the Book compiled by his
disciples. Rather, the contrary. ' The ten eyes and ten hands/
says Lo A r ung-fan, ' indicate all the spirits who know men's inmost
solitary thoughts.'



414



THE Li kL bk. xxxix.



They lead my thoughts to our duke Wu ; —

Of winning grace is he !
As knife and file make smooth the bone,
As jade by chisel wrought and stone,

Is stamp upon him set.
Grave and of dignity serene ;
With force of will as plainly seen ;
Accomplished, elegant in mien ;

Him we can ne'er forget.'

(That expression), ' as knife and file make smooth
the bone,' indicates the effect of learning. ' Like
jade by chisel wrought and stone' indicates that of
self-culture. 'Grave and of dignity serene' indicates
the feeling of cautious reverence. ' With force of
will as plainly seen' indicates an awe-inspiring
deportment. (The lines),

' Accomplished, elegant in mien,
Him can we ne'er forget,'
indicate how when virtue is complete, and excellence
extreme, the people cannot forget them.

8. It is said in the Book of Poetry (IV, i, ode 4),
' The former kings in mind still bear,

What glory can with theirs compare?.'
Superior men deem worthy whom they deemed
worthy, and love whom they loved. The inferior
people delight in what they delighted in, and are
benefited by their beneficial arrangements. It is
on this account that the former kings, after they
have quitted the world, are not forgotten.

9. It is said in the Announcement to the Prince
of Khang (Shu, V, ix, 3),

' He was able to make his virtue illustrious.'
It is said in the Thai Km, ' He kept his eye



BK. XXXIX. TA HSIO. 415

continually on the bright requirements of Heaven'
(Shu, III, v, sect. 1, 2).

It is said in the Canon of the Ti (Yao), ' He was
able to make illustrious his lofty virtue' (Shu, I, 2).

These (passages) all show how (those sovereigns)
made themselves illustrious.

10. On the bathing-tub of Thang 1 , the following
words were engraved, 'If you can one day renovate
yourself, do so from day to day. Yea, daily renovate
yourself/

In the Announcement to the Prince of Khang it
is said, ' Stir up the new people ' (Shu, V, ix, 7).
In the Book of Poetry it is said (III, i, 1, 1),

' The state of Kfku had long been known ;
Heaven's will as new at last was shown.'

Therefore the superior man in everything uses his
utmost endeavours 2 .

11. It is said in the Book of Poetry (IV, iii, 3),

' A thousand li extends the king's domain,
And there the people to repose are fain.'

And in another place (II, viii, 1),

' Twitters fast the oriole

Where yonder bends the mound,
The happy little creature
Its resting-place has found.'

The Master said, ' Yes, it rests ; it knows where



1 A fact not elsewhere noted. But such inscriptions are still
common in China.

2 The repeated use of ' new/ ' renovated,' in this paragraph, is
thought to justify the change of ' loving the people,' in paragraph 1,
to ' renovating the people ; ' but the object of the renovating here
is not the people.



41 6 THE LI Kl. BK. XXXIX.

to rest. Can one be a man, and yet not equal (in
this respect) to this bird ?'

12. It is said in the Book of Poetry (III, i, i, 4),
' Deep were Wan's thoughts, sustained his ways;

And reverent in each resting-place.'
As a ruler, he rested in benevolence ; as a
minister, he rested in respect ; as a son, he rested
in filial piety ; as a father, he rested in kindness ;
in intercourse with his subjects, he rested in good
faith.

13. The Master said, ' In hearing litigations, I am
like any other body.' What is necessary is to cause
the people to have no litigations, so that those who
are devoid of truth shall find it impossible to carry
out their speeches, and a great awe be struck into
the minds of the people.

1 4. This is called ' knowing the root V

15. What is meant by 'The cultivation of the
person depends on the rectifying of the mind ' (may
be thus illustrated) : — If a man be under the in-
fluence of anger, his conduct will not be correct.
The same will be the case, if he be under the
influence of terror, or of fond regard, or of sorrow
and distress. When the mind is not present, we
look and do not see ; we hear and do not under-
stand ; we eat and do not know the taste of what
we eat. This is what is meant by saying that ' the
cultivation of the person depends on the rectifying
of the mind.'

1 6. What is meant by ' The regulation of the
family depends on the cultivation of the person'

1 It is certainly difficult to see how paragraphs 13, 14 stand where
they do. Lo Aung-fan omits them.



BK. XXXIX. TA HSIO. 417

is this : — Men are partial where they feel affection
and love ; partial where they despise and dislike ;
partial where they stand in awe and with a feeling
of respect ; partial where they feel sorrow and com-
passion ; partial where they are arrogant and rude.
Thus it is that there are few men in the world who
love and at the same time know the bad qualities
(of the object of their love), or who hate and yet
know the good qualities (of the object of their
hatred). Hence it is said, in the common adage,
' A man does not know the badness of his son ; he
does not know the richness of his growing corn.'
This is what is meant by saying, that ' if his person
be not cultivated, a man cannot regulate his family.'

17. What is meant by 'In order to govern well
his state, it is necessary first to regulate his family'
is this : — It is not possible for one to teach others
while he cannot teach his own family. Therefore
the superior man (who governs a state), without
going beyond his family, completes the lessons for
his state. There is filial piety ; — it has its applica-
tion in the service of the ruler. There is brotherly
obedience ; — it has its application in the service of
elders. There is kindly gentleness; — it has its ap-
plication in the employment of the multitudes. It
is said in the Announcement to the Prince of
Khang (Shu, V, ix, 9), ' (Deal with the people),
as if you were watching over an infant.' If (a
mother) be really anxious about it, though she may
not hit (exactly the wants of her infant), she will not
be far from doing so. There never has been (a
girl) who learned (first) to bring up an infant that
she might afterwards be married.

18. From the loving (example) of one family,
[28] E e



41 8 THE LI kL



BK. XXXIX.



a whole state may become loving, and from its
courtesies, courteous, while from the ambition and
perverseness of the One man, the whole state may be
thrown into rebellious disorder; — such is the nature
of the influence. This is in accordance with the
saying, 'Affairs may be ruined by a single sentence ;
a state may be settled by its One man.'

19. Yao and Shun presided over the kingdom
with benevolence, and the people followed them.
ATieh and Aau did so with violence, and the people
followed them. When the orders of a ruler are
contrary to what he himself loves to practise the
people do not follow him.

20. Therefore the ruler must have in himself the
(good) qualities, and then he may require them in
others ; if they are not in himself, he cannot require
them in others. Never has there been a man who,
not having reference to his own character and wishes
in dealing with others, was able effectually to
instruct them. Thus we see how ' the government
of the state depends on the regulation of the family.'

21. In the Book of Poetry it is said (I, i, 6, 3),

1 Graceful and young the peach-tree stands,
Its foliage clustering green and full.
This bride to her new home repairs ;
Her household will attest her rule.'

Let the household be rightly ordered, and then the
people of the state may be taught.
In another ode it is said (II, ii, 9, 3),

' In concord with their brothers may they dwell ! '

Let rulers dwell in concord with all their brethren,
and then they may teach the people of their states.
In a third ode it is said (I, xiv, 3, 3),



bk. xxxix. TA HSIO. 419

' His movements without fault or flaw beeet

o

Good order for his rule throughout the state.'
When the ruler as a father, a son, an elder brother
or a younger, is a model for imitation, then the
people imitate him. These (passages) show how
' the government of a state depends on the regu-
lation of the family.'

22. What is meant by 'The making the whole
kingdom peaceful and happy depends on the govern-
ment of its states ' is this : — When the superiors
behave to their aged as the aged should be behaved
to, the people become filial ; when they behave to
their elders as elders should be behaved to, the
people learn brotherly submission ; when they treat
compassionately the young and helpless, the people
do the same. Thus the superior man has a principle
with which, as with a measuring square, to regulate
his course.

23. What a man dislikes in his superiors, let him
not display in his treatment of his inferiors; and what
he dislikes in his inferiors, let him not display in
his service of his superiors : what he dislikes in
those who are before him, let him not therewith
precede those who are behind him ; and what he
dislikes in those who are behind him, let him not
therewith follow those who are before him : what he
dislikes to receive on the right, let him not bestow
on the left ; and what he dislikes to receive on the
left, let him not bestow on the right : — this is what
is called ' The Principle with which, as with a
measuring square, to regulate one's course.'

24. In the Book of Poetry it is said (II, ii, 7, 3),

' To be rejoiced in are these noble men,

The parents of the people !'

E e 2



420 THE hi A'l. BK. XXXIX.

When (a ruler) loves what the people love, and
hates what the people hate, then is he what is called
' The Parent of the People.'

25. In the Book of Poetry it is said (II, iv, 7, 1),

' That southern hill, sublime, uprears its craggy
height ;
Such thou, Grand-master Yin, before the nation's
sight ! '

Rulers of states should not neglect to be careful.
If they deviate (to a selfish regard only for them-
selves), they will be counted a disgrace throughout
the kingdom.

26. In the Book of Poetry it is said (III, i, 1,6),

' Ere Shang had lost the nation's heart,
Its monarchs all with God had part
In sacrifice. From them we see
'Tis hard to keep High Heaven's decree.'

This shows that by gaining the people, the state is
gained ; and by losing the people, the state is lost.

Therefore the ruler should first be careful about
his (own) virtue. Possessing virtue will give him
the people. Possessing the people will give him the
territory. Possessing the territory will give him its
wealth. Possessing the wealth, he will have re- sources for expenditure.