Angelico's St. Dominic appropriately watches over the Chapter
House, which contains the largest of Fra Giovanni's frescoes and one of
the greatest masterpieces of religious art: the Crucifixion with
the patron saints of Florence, of the convent, and of the Medici,
the founders of the religious orders, the representatives of the zeal
and learning of the Dominicans, all gathered and united in
contemplation around the Cross of Christ. It was ordered by Cosimo dei
Medici, and painted about 1441. On our left are the Madonna, supported by
the Magdalene, the other Mary, and the beloved Disciple; the Baptist
and St. Mark, representing the city and the convent; St. Lawrence and
St. Cosmas (said by Vasari to be a portrait of Nanni di Banco, who
died twenty years before), and St. Damian. On our right, kneeling at
the foot of the Cross, is St. Dominic, a masterpiece of expression
and sentiment; behind him St. Augustine and St. Albert of
Jerusalem represent Augustinians and Carmelites; St. Jerome, St. Francis,
St. Bernard, St. John Gualbert kneel; St. Benedict and St. Romuald
stand behind them, while at the end are St. Peter Martyr and St.
Thomas Aquinas. All the male heads are admirably characterised
and discriminated, unlike Angelico's women, who are usually either
merely conventionally done or idealised into Angels. Round the picture is
a frieze of prophets, culminating in the mystical Pelican; below is
the great tree of the Dominican order, spreading out from St.
Dominic himself in the centre, with Popes Innocent V. and Benedict XI.
on either hand. The St. Antoninus was added later. Vasari tells us
that, in this tree, the brothers of the order assisted Angelico by
obtaining portraits of the various personages represented from different
places; and they may therefore be regarded as the real, or
traditional, likenesses of the great Dominicans. The same probably applies to
the wonderful figure of Aquinas in the picture itself.
Beyond is a
second and larger cloister, surrounded by very inferior frescoes of the life
of St. Dominic, full of old armorial bearings and architectural fragments
arranged rather incongruously. Some of the lunettes over the cells contain
frescoes of the school of Fra Bartolommeo. The Academy of the Crusca is
established here, in what was once the dormitory of the Novices. Connected
with this cloister was the convent garden. "In the summer time," writes
Simone Filipepi, "in the evening after supper, the Father Fra Girolamo used
to walk with his friars in the garden, and he would make them all sit
round him with the Bible in his hand, and here he expounded to them
some fair passage of the Scriptures, sometimes questioning some novice
or other, as occasion arose. At these meetings there gathered also
some fifty or sixty learned laymen, for their edification. When, by
reason of rain or other cause, it was not possible in the garden, they
went into the _hospitium_ to do the same; and for an hour or two one
seemed verily to be in Paradise, such charity and devotion and
simplicity appeared in all. Blessed was he who could be there." Shortly
before the Ordeal of Fire, Fra Girolamo was walking in the garden with
Fra Placido Cinozzi, when an exceedingly beautiful boy of noble
family came to him with a ticket upon which was written his name,
offering himself to pass through the flames. And thinking that this might
not be sufficient, he fell upon his knees, begging the Friar that he
might be allowed to undergo the ordeal for him. "Rise up, my son,"
said Savonarola, "for this thy good will is wondrously pleasing unto
God"; and, when the boy had gone, he turned to Fra Placido and said:
"From many persons have I had these applications, but from none have
I received so much joy as from this child, for which may God
be praised."
To the left of the staircase to the upper floor, is the
smaller refectory with a fresco of the Last Supper by Domenico
Ghirlandaio, not by any means one of the painter's best works.
On the
top of the stairs we are initiated into the spirit of the place by Angelico's
most beautiful Annunciation, with its inscription, _Virginis intacte cum
veneris ante figuram, pretereundo cave ne sileatur Ave_, "When thou shalt
have come before the image of the spotless Virgin, beware lest by negligence
the Ave be silent."
On the left of the stairway a double series of cells
on either side of the corridor leads us to Savonarola's room. At the head of
the corridor is one of those representations that Angelico repeated
so often, usually with modifications, of St. Dominic at the foot of
the Cross. Each of the cells has a painted lyric of the life of Christ
and His mother, from Angelico's hand; almost each scene with
Dominican witnesses and auditors introduced,--Dominic, Aquinas, Peter Martyr,
as the case may be. In these frescoes Angelico was undoubtedly assisted by
pupils, from whom a few of the less excellent scenes may come; there is an
interesting, but altogether untrustworthy tradition that some were executed
by his brother, Fra Benedetto da Mugello, who took the Dominican habit
simultaneously with him and was Prior of the convent at Fiesole. Taking the
cells on the left first, we see the _Noli me tangere_ (1), the Entombment
(2), the Annunciation (3), the Crucifixion (4), the Nativity (5), the
Transfiguration (6), a most wonderful picture. Opposite the Transfiguration,
on the right wall of the corridor, is a Madonna and Saints, painted by the
Friar somewhat later than the frescoes in the cells (which, it should be
observed, appear to have been painted on the walls before the cells
were actually partitioned off)--St. John Evangelist and St. Mark, the
three great Dominicans and the patrons of the Medici. Then, on the left,
the following cells contain the Mocking of Christ (7), the
Resurrection with the Maries at the tomb (8), the Coronation of the Madonna
(9), one of the grandest of the whole series, with St. Dominic and
St. Francis kneeling below, and behind them St. Benedict and St.
Thomas Aquinas, St. Peter Martyr and St. Paul the Hermit. The Presentation
in the Temple (10), and the Madonna and Child with Aquinas and
Augustine (11), are inferior to the rest.
The shorter passage now
turns to the cells occupied by Fra Girolamo Savonarola; one large cell
leading into two smaller ones (12-14). In the larger are placed three
frescoes by Fra Bartolommeo; Christ and the two disciples at Emmaus, formerly
over the doorway of the refectory, and two Madonnas--one from the Dominican
convent in the Mugnone being especially beautiful. Here are also modern busts
of Savonarola by Dupre and Benivieni by Bastianini. In the first
inner cell are Savonarola's portrait, apparently copied from a medal
and wrongly ascribed to Bartolommeo, his Crucifix and his relics,
his manuscripts and books of devotion, and, in another case, his
hair shirt and rosary, his beloved Dominican garb which he gave up on
the day of his martyrdom. In the inmost cell are the Cross which he
is said to have carried, and a copy of the old (but not
contemporary) picture of his death, of which the original is in the Corsini
Palace.
The seven small cells on the right (15-21) were assigned to
the Juniors, the younger friars who had just passed through the
Noviciate. Each contains a fresco by Angelico of St. Dominic at the foot of
the Cross, now scourging himself, now absorbed in contemplation,
now covering his face with his hands, but in no two cases identical.
Into one of these cells a divine apparition was said to have come to one
of these youths, after hearing Savonarola's "most fervent and
most wondrous discourse" upon the mystery of the Incarnation. The story
is told by Simone Filipepi:--
"On the night of the most Holy Nativity,
to a young friar in the convent, who had not yet sung Mass, had appeared
visibly in his cell on the little altar, whilst he was engaged in prayer, Our
Lord in the form of a little infant even as when He was born in the stable.
And when the hour came to go into the choir for matins, the said
friar commenced to debate in his mind whether he ought to go and leave
here the Holy Child, and deprive himself of such sweetness, or not. At
last he resolved to go and to bear It with him; so, having wrapped It up
in his arms and under his cowl as best he could, all trembling with
joy and with fear, he went down into the choir without telling
anyone. But, when it came to his turn to sing a lesson, whilst he
approached the reading-desk, the Infant vanished from his arms; and when
the friar was aware of this, he remained so overwhelmed and almost
beside himself that he commenced to wander through the choir, like one
who seeks a thing lost, so that it was necessary that another should
read that lesson."
Passing back again down the corridor, we see in the
cells two more Crucifixions (22 and 23); the Baptism of Christ with Madonna
as witness (24), the Crucifixion (25); then, passing the great
Madonna fresco, the Mystery of the Passion (26), in one of those
symbolical representations which seem to have originated with the
Camaldolese painter, Don Lorenzo; Christ bound to the pillar, with St.
Dominic scourging himself and the Madonna appealing to us (27, perhaps by
a pupil); Christ bearing the Cross (28); two more Crucifixions (29
and 30), apparently not executed by Angelico himself.
At the side of
Angelico's Annunciation opposite the stairs, we enter the cell of St.
Antoninus (31). Here is one of Angelico's most beautiful and characteristic
frescoes, Christ's descent into Hades: "the intense, fixed, statue-like
silence of ineffable adoration upon the spirits in prison at the feet of
Christ, side by side, the hands lifted and the knees bowed, and the lips
trembling together," as Ruskin describes it. Here, too, is the death mask of
Antoninus, his portrait perhaps drawn from the death mask by Bartolommeo,
his manuscripts and relics; also a tree of saintly Dominicans,
Savonarola being on the main trunk, the third from the root.
The next
cell on the right (32) has the Sermon on the Mount and the Temptation in the
Wilderness. In the following (33), also double, besides the frescoed Kiss of
Judas, are two minute pictures by Fra Angelico, belonging to an earlier stage
of his art than the frescoes, intended for reliquaries and formerly in Santa
Maria Novella. One of them, the _Madonna della Stella_, is a very perfect and
typical example of the Friar's smaller works, in their "purity of
colour almost shadowless." The other, the Coronation of the Madonna, is
less excellent and has suffered from retouching. The Agony in the
Garden (in cell 34) contains a curious piece of mediæval symbolism in
the presence of Mary and Martha, contemplation and action, the Mary
being here the Blessed Virgin. In the same cell is another of
the reliquaries from Santa Maria Novella, the Annunciation over
the Adoration of the Magi, with Madonna and Child, the Virgin Martyrs,
the Magdalene and St. Catherine of Siena below; the drawing is
rather faulty. In the following cells are the Last Supper (35),
conceived mystically as the institution of the Blessed Sacrament of the
Altar, with the Madonna alone as witness; the Deposition from the Cross
(36); and the Crucifixion (37), in which Dominic stands with
out-stretched arms.
Opposite on the right (38-39) is the great cell
where Pope Eugenius stayed on the occasion of the consecration of San Marco
in 1442; here Cosimo the Elder, Pater Patriae, spent long hours of his
closing days, in spiritual intercourse with St. Antoninus and after the
latter's death. In the outer compartment the Medicean saint, Cosmas,
joins Madonna and Peter Martyr at the foot of the Cross. Within are
the Adoration of the Magi and a Pieta, both from Angelico's hand, and
the former, one of his latest masterpieces, probably painted
with reference to the fact that the convent had been consecrated on
the Feast of the Epiphany. Here, too, is an old terracotta bust
of Antoninus, and a splendid but damaged picture of Cosimo himself
by Jacopo da Pontormo, incomparably finer than that artist's
similarly constructed work in the Uffizi. Between two smaller cells
containing Crucifixions, both apparently by Angelico himself (42-43--the
former with the Mary and Martha motive at the foot of the Cross), is
the great Greek Library, built by Michelozzo for Cosimo. Here
Cosimo deposited a portion of the manuscripts which had been collected
by Niccolo Niccoli, with additions of his own, and it became the
first public library in Italy. Its shelves are now empty and bare, but
it contains a fine collection of illuminated ritual books from
suppressed convents, several of which are, rather doubtfully, ascribed
to Angelico's brother, Fra Benedetto da Mugello.
It was in this
library that Savonarola exercised for the last time his functions of Prior of
San Marco, and surrendered to the commissioners of the Signoria, on the night
of Palm Sunday, 1498. What happened had best be told in the words of the
Padre Pacifico Burlamacchi of the same convent, Savonarola's contemporary and
follower. After several fictitious summonses had come:--
"They
returned at last with the decree of the Signoria in writing, but with the
open promise that Fra Girolamo should be restored safe and sound, together
with his companions. When he heard this, he told them that he would obey. But
first he retired with his friars into the Greek Library, where he made them
in Latin a most beautiful sermon, exhorting them to follow onwards in the way
of God with faith, prayer, and patience; telling them that it was necessary
to go to heaven by the way of tribulations, and that therefore they ought not
in any way to be terrified; alleging many old examples of the ingratitude of
the city of Florence in return for the benefits received from their
Order. As that of St. Peter Martyr who, after doing so many marvellous
things in Florence, was slain, the Florentines paying the price of his
blood. And of St. Catherine of Siena, whom many had sought to kill, after
she had borne so many labours for them, going personally to Avignon
to plead their cause before the Pope. Nor had less happened to
St. Antoninus, their Archbishop and excellent Pastor, whom they had
once wished to throw from the windows. And that it was no marvel, if
he also, after such sorrows and labourings, was paid at the end in
the same coin. But that he was ready to receive everything with desire
and happiness for the love of his Lord, knowing that in nought
else consisted the Christian life, save in doing good and suffering
evil. And thus, while all the bye-standers wept, he finished his
sermon. Then, issuing forth from the library, he said to those laymen
who awaited him: 'I will say to you what Jeremiah said: This thing
I expected, but not so soon nor so suddenly.' He exhorted them further to
live well and to be fervent in prayer. And having confessed to the Father Fra
Domenico da Pescia, he took the Communion in the first library. And the same
did Fra Domenico. After eating a little, he was somewhat refreshed; and he
spoke the last words to his friars, exhorting them to persevere in religion,
and kissing them all, he took his last departure from them. In the parting
one of his children said to him: 'Father, why dost thou abandon us and leave
us so desolate?' To which he replied: 'Son, have patience, God will help
you'; and he added that he would either see them again alive, or that after
death he would appear to them without fail. Also, as he departed, he gave
up the common keys to the brethren, with so great humility and
charity, that the friars could not keep themselves from tears; and many of
them wished by all means to go with him. At last, recommending himself
to their prayers, he made his way towards the door of the library,
where the first Commissioners all armed were awaiting him; to whom,
giving himself into their hands like a most meek lamb, he said: 'I
recommend to you this my flock and all these other citizens.' And when he was
in the corridor of the library, he said: 'My friars, doubt not, for
God will not fail to perfect His work; and although I be put to death,
I shall help you more than I have done in life, and I will return without
fail to console you, either dead or alive.' Arrived at the holy water, which
is at the exit of the choir, Fra Domenico said to him: 'Fain would I too come
to these nuptials.' Certain of the laymen, his friends, were arrested at the
command of the Signoria. When the Father Fra Girolamo was in the first
cloister, Fra Benedetto, the miniaturist, strove ardently to go with him;
and, when the officers thrust him back, he still insisted that he would go.
But the Father Fra Girolamo turned to him, and said: 'Fra Benedetto, on
your obedience come not, for I and Fra Domenico have to die for the love
of Christ.' And thus he was torn away from the eyes of his
children."
CHAPTER X
_The Accademia delle Belle
Arti--The Santissima Annunziata--And other Buildings_
"In
Firenze, piu che altrove, venivano gli uomini perfetti in tutte l'arti,
e specialmente nella pittura."--_Vasari._
Turning southwards from the
Piazza di San Marco into the Via Ricasoli, we come to the _Accademia delle
Belle Arti_, with its collection of Tuscan and Umbrian pictures, mostly
gathered from suppressed churches and convents.
In the central hall,
the Tribune of the David, Michelangelo's gigantic marble youth stands under
the cupola, surrounded by casts of the master's other works. The young hero
has just caught sight of the approaching enemy, and is all braced up for the
immortal moment. Commenced in 1501 and finished at the beginning of 1504, out
of a block of marble over which an earlier sculptor had bungled, it
was originally set up in front of the Palazzo Vecchio on the Ringhiera,
as though to defend the great Palace of the People. It is supposed to have
taken five days to move the statue from the Opera del Duomo, where
Michelangelo had chiselled it out, to the Palace. When the simple-minded
Gonfaloniere, Piero Soderini, saw it, he told the artist that the nose
appeared to him to be too large; whereupon Michelangelo mounted a ladder,
pretended to work upon it for a few moments, dropping a little marble dust
all the time, which he had taken up with him, and then turned round for
approval to the Gonfaloniere, who assured him that he had now given the
statue life. This _gigante di Fiorenza_, as it was called, was considerably
damaged during the third expulsion of the Medici in 1527, but retained its
proud position before the Palace until 1873.
On the right, as we
approach the giant, is the _Sala del Beato Angelico_, containing a lovely
array of Fra Angelico's smaller paintings. Were we to attempt to sum up
Angelico's chief characteristics in one word, that word would be _onesta_, in
its early mediaeval sense as Dante uses it in the _Vita Nuova_, signifying
not merely purity or chastity, as it came later to mean, but the
outward manifestation of spiritual beauty,--the _honestas_ of which
Aquinas speaks. A supreme expression of this may be found in the Paradise
of his Last Judgment (266), the mystical dance of saints and Angels in the
celestial garden that blossoms under the rays of the Sun of Divine Love, and
on all the faces of the blessed beneath the Queen of Mercy on the Judge's
right. The Hell is, naturally, almost a failure. In many of the small scenes
from the lives of Christ and His Mother, of which there are several complete
series here, some of the heads are absolute miracles of expression; notice,
for instance, the Judas receiving the thirty pieces of silver, and all the
faces in the Betrayal (237), and, above all perhaps, the Peter in the Entry
into Jerusalem (252), on every line of whose face seems written: "Lord,
why can I not follow thee now? I will lay down my life for thy sake."
The Deposition from the Cross (246), contemplated by St. Dominic,
the Beata Villana and St. Catherine of Alexandria, appears to be
an earlier work of Angelico's. Here, also, are three great
Madonnas painted by the Friar as altar pieces for convent churches; the
Madonna and Child surrounded by Angels and saints, while Cosmas and
Damian, the patrons of the Medici, kneel at her feet (281), was executed
in 1438 for the high altar of San Marco, and, though now terribly injured,
was originally one of his best pictures; the Madonna and Child, with two
Angels and six saints, Peter Martyr, Cosmas and Damian, Francis, Antony of
Padua, and Louis of Toulouse (265), was painted for the convent of the
Osservanza near Mugello,--hence the group of Franciscans on the left; the
third (227), in which Cosmas and Damian stand with St. Dominic on the right
of the Madonna, and St. Francis with Lawrence and John the Divine on her
left, is an inferior work from his hand.
Also in this room are four
delicious little panels by Lippo Lippi (264 and 263), representing the
Annunciation divided into two compartments, St. Antony Abbot and the Baptist;
two Monks of the Vallombrosa, by Perugino (241, 242), almost worthy of
Raphael; and two charming scenes of mediaeval university life, the School of
Albertus Magnus (231) and the School of St. Thomas Aquinas (247). These two
latter appear to be by some pupil of Fra Angelico, and may possibly be very
early works of Benozzo Gozzoli. In the first, Albert is lecturing to an
audience, partly lay and partly clerical, amongst whom is St. Thomas, then
a youthful novice but already distinguished by the halo and the sun
upon his breast; in the second, Thomas himself is now holding
the professorial chair, surrounded by pupils listening or taking
notes, while Dominicans throng the cloisters behind. On his right sits
the King of France; below his seat the discomforted Averrhoes
humbly places himself on the lowest step, between the heretics--William
of St. Amour and Sabellius.
From the left of the David's tribune, we
turn into three rooms containing masterpieces of the Quattrocento (with a few
later works), and appropriately named after Botticelli and
Perugino.
In the _Sala prima del Botticelli_ is Sandro's famous
_Primavera_, the Allegory of Spring or the Kingdom of Venus (80). Inspired in
part by Poliziano's _stanze_ in honour of Giuliano dei Medici and his
Bella Simonetta, Botticelli nevertheless has given to his
strange--not altogether decipherable--allegory, a vague mysterious poetry
far beyond anything that Messer Angelo could have suggested to
him. Through this weirdly coloured garden of the Queen of Love, in
"the light that never was on sea or land," blind Cupid darts upon
his little wings, shooting, apparently at random, a flame-tipped
arrow which will surely pierce the heart of the central maiden of
those three, who, in their thin clinging white raiment, personify
the Graces. The eyes of Simonetta--for it is clearly she--rest for
a moment in the dance upon the stalwart Hermes, an idealised Giuliano, who
has turned away carelessly from the scene. Flora, "pranked and pied for
birth," advances from our right, scattering flowers rapidly as she
approaches; while behind her a wanton Zephyr, borne on his strong wings,
breaks through the wood to clasp Fertility, from whose mouth the flowers are
starting. Venus herself, the mistress of nature, for whom and by whom all
these things are done, stands somewhat sadly apart in the centre of the
picture; this is only one more of the numberless springs that have passed
over her since she first rose from the sea, and she is somewhat weary of it
all:--
"Te, dea, te fugiunt venti, te nubila caeli
Adventumque tuum, tibi suavis daedala tellus Summittit flores, tibi
rident aequora ponti Placatumque nitet diffuso lumine
caelum."[47]
[47] "Before thee, goddess, flee the winds, the clouds of
heaven; before thee and thy advent; for thee earth manifold in works
puts forth sweet-smelling flowers; for thee the levels of the sea do
laugh and heaven propitiated shines with outspread light"
(Munro's _Lucretius_).
This was one of the pictures painted for
Lorenzo the Magnificent. Botticelli's other picture in this room, the large
Coronation of the Madonna (73) with its predella (74), was commissioned by
the Arte di Por Sta. Maria, the Guild of Silk-merchants, for an altar in
San Marco; the ring of festive Angels, encircling their King and Queen,
is in one of the master's most characteristic moods. On either side of the
Primavera are two early works by Lippo Lippi; Madonna adoring the Divine
Child in a rocky landscape, with the little St. John and an old hermit (79),
and the Nativity (82), with Angels and shepherds, Jerome, Magdalene and
Hilarion. Other important pictures in this room are Andrea del Sarto's Four
Saints (76), one of his latest works painted for the monks of Vallombrosa in
1528; Andrea Verrocchio's Baptism of Christ (71), in which the two Angels
were possibly painted by Verrocchio's great pupil, Leonardo, in his youth;
Masaccio's Madonna and Child watched over by St. Anne (70), an early and
damaged work, the only authentic easel picture of his in Florence. The three
small predella pictures (72), the Nativity, the martyrdom of Sts. Cosmas
and Damian, St. Anthony of Padua finding a stone in the place of the
dead miser's heart, by Francesco Pesellino, 1422-1457, the pupil of
Lippo Lippi, are fine examples of a painter who normally only worked on
this small scale and whose works are very rare indeed. Francesco
Granacci, who painted the Assumption (68), is chiefly interesting as
having been Michelangelo's friend and fellow pupil under
Ghirlandaio.
The _Sala del Perugino_ takes its name from three works of
that master which it contains; the great Vallombrosa Assumption (57), signed
and dated 1500, one of the painter's finest altar pieces, with a
very characteristic St. Michael--the Archangel who was by tradition
the genius of the Assumption, as Gabriel had been of the Annunciation;
the Deposition from the Cross (56); and the Agony in the Garden (53).
But the gem of the whole room is Lippo Lippi's Coronation of the
Madonna (62), one of the masterpieces of the early Florentine school, which
he commenced for the nuns of Sant' Ambrogio in 1441. The throngs of
boys and girls, bearing lilies and playing at being Angels, are
altogether delightful, and the two little orphans, that are being petted by
the pretty Florentine lady on our right, are characteristic of
Fra Filippo's never failing sympathy with child life. On the left
two admirably characterised monks are patronised by St. Ambrose, and
in the right corner the jolly Carmelite himself, under the wing of
the Baptist, is welcomed by a little Angel with the scroll, _Is
perfecit opus_. It will be observed that "poor brother Lippo" has
dressed himself with greater care for his celestial visit, than he
announced his intention of doing in Robert Browning's
poem:--
"Well, all these Secured at their
devotion, up shall come Out of a corner when you least expect,
As one by a dark stair into a great light, Music and talking, who but
Lippo! I!-- Mazed, motionless and moon-struck--I'm the man! Back
I shrink--what is this I see and hear? I, caught up with my monk's
things by mistake, My old serge gown and rope that goes all
round, I, in this presence, this pure company! Where's a hole,
where's a corner for escape? Then steps a sweet angelic slip of a
thing Forward, puts out a soft palm--'Not so fast!' Addresses
the celestial presence, 'Nay-- 'He made you and devised you, after
all, 'Though he's none of you! Could Saint John there draw--
'His camel-hair make up a painting-brush? 'We come to brother Lippo for
all that, '_Iste perfecit opus!_'"
Fra Filippo's Madonna and
Child, with Sts. Cosmas and Damian, Francis and Antony, painted for the
Medicean chapel in Santa Croce (55), is an earlier and less characteristic
work. Over the door is St. Vincent preaching, by Fra Bartolommeo (58),
originally painted to go over the entrance to the sacristy in San Marco--a
striking representation of a Dominican preacher of repentance and renovation,
conceived in the spirit of Savonarola, but terribly "restored." The Trinita
(63) is one of Mariotto Albertinelli's best works, but sadly damaged. The
two child Angels (61) by Andrea del Sarto, originally belonged to
his picture of the Four Saints, in the last room; the Crucifixion,
with the wonderful figure of the Magdalene at the foot of the Cross
(65), ascribed to Luca Signorelli, does not appear to be from the
master's own hand; Ghirlandaio's predella (67), with scenes from the lives
of Sts. Dionysius, Clement, Dominic, and Thomas Aquinas, belongs to
a great picture which we shall see presently.
The _Sala seconda del
Botticelli_ contains three pictures ascribed to the master, but only one is
authentic--the Madonna and Child enthroned with six Saints, while Angels
raise the curtain over her throne or hold up emblems of the Passion (85); it
is inscribed with Dante's line--
"Vergine Madre, Figlia del tuo
Figlio."
The familiar Three Archangels (84), though attributed to Sandro,
is not even a work of his school. There is a charming little
predella picture by Fra Filippo (86), representing a miracle of San
Frediano, St. Michael announcing her death to the Blessed Virgin, and a
friar contemplating the mystery of the Blessed Trinity--pierced by
the "three arrows of the three stringed bow," to adopt Dante's phrase.
The Deposition from the Cross (98), was commenced by Filippino Lippi
for the Annunziata, and finished after his death in 1504 by Perugino,
who added the group of Maries with the Magdalene and the figure on
our right. The Vision of St. Bernard (97), by Fra Bartolommeo, is
the first picture that the Friar undertook on resuming his brush,
after Raphael's visit to Florence had stirred him up to new
efforts; commenced in 1506, it was left unfinished, and has been injured
by renovations. Here are two excellent paintings by Lorenzo di Credi
(92 and 94), the former, the Adoration of the Shepherds, being his
very best and most perfectly finished work. High up are two figures
in niches by Filippino Lippi, the Baptist and the Magdalene (93 and
89), hardly pleasing. The Resurrection (90), by Raffaellino del Garbo,
is the only authentic work in Florence of a pupil of Filippino's, who gave
great promise which was never fulfilled.
At the end of the hall are three
Sale _dei Maestri Toscani_, from the earliest Primitives down to the
eighteenth century. Only a few need concern us much.
The first room
contains the works of the earlier masters, from a pseudo-Cimabue (102), to
Luca Signorelli, whose Madonna and Child with Archangels and Doctors (164),
painted for a church in Cortona, has suffered from restoration. There are
four genuine, very tiny pictures by Botticelli (157, 158, 161, 162). The
Adoration of the Kings (165), by Gentile da Fabriano, is one of the most
delightful old pictures in Florence; Gentile da Fabriano, an Umbrian master
who, through Jacopo Bellini, had a considerable influence upon the early
Venetian school, settled in Florence in 1422, and finished this picture in
the following year for Santa Trinita, near which he kept a much
frequented bottega. Michelangelo said that Gentile had a hand similar to
his name; and this picture, with its rich and varied poetry, is
his masterpiece. The man wearing a turban, seen full face behind the
third king, is the painter himself. Kugler remarks: "Fra Angelico
and Gentile are like two brothers, both highly gifted by nature, both
full of the most refined and amiable feelings; but the one became a
monk, the other a knight." The smaller pictures surrounding it are
almost equally charming in their way--especially, perhaps, the Flight
into Egypt in the predella. The Deposition from the Cross (166), by
Fra Angelico, also comes from Santa Trinita, for which it was finished
in 1445; originally one of Angelico's masterpieces, it has been
badly repainted; the saints in the frame are extremely beautiful,
especially a most wonderful St. Michael at the top, on our left; the man
standing on the ladder, wearing a black hood, is the architect, Michelozzo,
who was the Friar's friend, and may be recognised in several of
his paintings. The lunettes in the three Gothic arches above
Angelico's picture, and which, perhaps, did not originally belong to it, are
by the Camaldolese Don Lorenzo, by whom are also the Annunciation
with four Saints (143), and the three predella scenes (144, 145,
146).
Of the earlier pictures, the Madonna and Child adored by Angels
(103) is now believed to be the only authentic easel picture of
Giotto's that remains to us--though this is, possibly, an excess of
scepticism. Besides several works ascribed to Taddeo Gaddi and his son
Agnolo, by the former of whom are probably the small panels from Santa
Croce, formerly attributed to Giotto, we should notice the Pieta by
Giovanni da Milano (131); the Presentation in the Temple by Ambrogio
Lorenzetti (134), signed and dated 1342; and a large altarpiece ascribed
to Pietro Cavallini (157). The so-called Marriage of Boccaccio
Adimari with Lisa Ricasoli (147) is an odd picture of the social customs
of old Florence.
In the second room are chiefly works by Fra
Bartolommeo and Mariotto Albertinelli. By the Frate, are the series of heads
of Christ and Saints (168), excepting the Baptist on the right; they are
frescoes taken from San Marco, excepting the Christ on the left,
inscribed "Orate pro pictore 1514," which is in oil on canvas. Also by him
are the two frescoes of Madonna and Child (171, 173), and the
splendid portrait of Savonarola in the character of St. Peter Martyr (172),
the great religious persecutor of the Middle Ages, to whom Fra
Girolamo had a special devotion. By Albertinelli, are the Madonna and
Saints (167), and the Annunciation (169), signed and dated 1510. This
room also contains several pictures by Fra Paolino da Pistoia and
the Dominican nun, Plautilla Nelli, two pious but insipid artists,
who inherited Fra Bartolommeo's drawings and tried to carry on
his traditions. On a stand in the middle of the room, is
Domenico Ghirlandaio's Adoration of the Shepherds (195), from Santa Trinita,
a splendid work with--as Vasari puts it--"certain heads of shepherds which
are held a divine thing."
On the walls of the third room are later
pictures of no importance or significance. But in the middle of the room is
another masterpiece by Ghirlandaio (66); the Madonna and Child with two
Angels, Thomas Aquinas and Dionysius standing on either side of the throne,
Dominic and Clement kneeling. It is seldom, indeed, that this prosaic
painter succeeded in creating such a thinker as this Thomas, such a mystic
as this Dionysius; in the head of the latter we see indeed the image
of the man who, according to the pleasant mediæval fable eternalised
by Dante, "in the flesh below, saw deepest into the Angelic nature and its
ministry."
* * * * *
In the Via
Cavour, beyond San Marco, is the _Chiostro dello Scalzo_, a cloister
belonging to a brotherhood dedicated to St. John, which was suppressed in the
eighteenth century. Here are a series of frescoes painted in grisaille by
Andrea del Sarto and his partner, Francia Bigio, representing scenes from the
life of the Precursor, with allegorical figures of the Virtues. The Baptism
of Christ is the earliest, and was painted by the two artists in
collaboration, in 1509 or 1510. After some work for the Servites, which we
shall see presently, Andrea returned to this cloister; and painted, from 1515
to 1517, the Justice, St. John preaching, St. John baptising the
people, and his imprisonment. Some of the figures in these frescoes show
the influence of Albert Durer's engravings. Towards the end of
1518, Andrea went off to France to work for King Francis I.; and, while
he was away, Francia Bigio painted St. John leaving his parents, and
St. John's first meeting with Christ. On Andrea's return, he set to
work here again and painted, at intervals from 1520 to 1526, Charity,
Faith and Hope, the dance of the daughter of Herodias, the decollation
of St. John, and the presentation of his head, the Angel appearing
to Zacharias, the Visitation, and, last of all, the Birth of the
Baptist. The Charity is Andrea's own wife, Lucrezia, who at this very time,
if Vasari's story is true, was persuading him to break his promise to
the French King and to squander the money which had been intrusted to
him for the purchase of works of art.
The Via della Sapienza leads
from San Marco into the _Piazza della Santissima Annunziata_. In one of the
houses on the left, now incorporated into the Reale Istituto di Studi
Superiori, Andrea del Sarto and Francia Bigio lodged with other painters,
before Andrea's marriage; and here, usually under the presidency of the
sculptor Rustici, the "Compagnia del Paiuolo," an artists' club of
twelve members, met for feasting and disport.[48]
[48] See _Andrea
del Sarto_, by H. Guinness in the _Great Masters_ series, and _G. F.
Rustici_ in Vasari.
This Piazza was a great place for processions in old
Florence. Here stand the church of the _Santissima Annunziata_ and the
convent of the Servites, while the Piazza itself is flanked to right and left
by arcades originally designed by Brunelleschi. The equestrian statue
of the Grand Duke Ferdinand I. was cast by Giovanni da Bologna out
of metal from captured Turkish guns. The arcade on the right, as we
face the church, with its charming medallions of babies in
swaddling clothes by Andrea della Robbia, is a part of the Spedale
degli Innocenti or Hospital for Foundlings, which was commenced
from Brunelleschi's designs in 1421, during the Gonfalonierate of
Giovanni dei Medici; the work, which was eloquently supported in the Council
of the People by Leonardo Bruni, was raised by the Silk-merchants
Guild, the Arte di Por Santa Maria. On its steps the Compagnacci
murdered their first victim in the attack on San Marco. There is a
picturesque court, designed by Brunelleschi, with an Annunciation by Andrea
della Robbia over the door of the chapel, and a small picture gallery,
which contains nothing of much importance, save a Holy Family with Saints
by Piero di Cosimo. In the chapel, or church of Santa Maria
degli Innocenti, there is a masterpiece by Domenico Ghirlandaio, painted
in 1488, an Adoration of the Magi (the fourth head on the left is
the painter himself), in which the Massacre of the Innocents is seen
in the background, and two of these glorified infant martyrs, under
the protection of the two St. Johns, are kneeling most sweetly in front
of the Madonna and her Child, for whom they have died, joining in
the adoration of the kings and the _gloria_ of the angelic choir.
The
church of the Santissima Annunziata was founded in the thirteenth century,
but has been completely altered and modernised since at different epochs. In
summer mornings lilies and other flowers lie in heaps in its portico and
beneath Ghirlandaio's mosaic of the Annunciation, to be offered at Madonna's
shrine within. The entrance court was built in the fifteenth century, at the
expense of the elder Piero dei Medici. The fresco to the left of the
entrance, the Nativity of Christ, is by Alessio Baldovinetti. Within the
glass, to the left, are six frescoes representing the life and miracles of
the great Servite, Filippo Benizzi; that of his receiving the habit of the
order is by Cosimo Rosselli (1476); the remaining five are early works
by Andrea del Sarto, painted in 1509 and 1510, for which he received
a mere trifle; in the midst of them is an indifferent seventeenth century
bust of their painter. The frescoes on the right, representing the life of
the Madonna, of whom this order claims to be the special servants, are
slightly later. The approach of the Magi and the Nativity of the Blessed
Virgin, the latter dated 1514, are among the finest works of Andrea del
Sarto; in the former he has introduced himself and the sculptor Sansovino,
and among the ladies in the latter is his wife. Fifty years afterwards the
painter Jacopo da Empoli was copying this picture, when a very old lady, who
was going into the church to hear mass, stopped to look at his work, and
then, pointing to the portrait of Lucrezia, told him that it was herself.
The Sposalizio, by Francia Bigio, painted in 1513, was damaged by
the painter himself in a fit of passion at the meddling of the monks.
The Visitation, by Jacopo da Pontormo, painted in 1516, shows
what admirable work this artist could do in his youth, before he fell
into his mannered imitations of Michelangelo; the Assumption,
painted slightly later by another of Andrea's pupils, Rosso Fiorentino,
is less excellent.
Inside the church itself, on the left, is the
sanctuary of Our Lady of the Annunciation, one of the most highly revered
shrines in Tuscany; it was constructed from the designs of Michelozzo at the
cost of the elder Piero dei Medici to enclose the miraculous picture of
the Annunciation, and lavishly decorated and adorned by the Medicean
Grand Dukes. After the Pazzi conspiracy, Piero's son Lorenzo had a
waxen image of himself suspended here in thanksgiving for his escape.
Over the altar there is usually a beautiful little head of the Saviour,
by Andrea del Sarto. The little oratory beyond, with the
Madonna's mystical emblems on its walls, was constructed in the
seventeenth century.
In the second chapel from the shrine is a fresco
by Andrea del Castagno, which was discovered in the summer of 1899 under a
copy of Michelangelo's Last Judgment. It represents St. Jerome and two
women saints adoring the Blessed Trinity, and is characteristic of the
_modo terribile_ in which this painter conceived his subjects; the heads
of the Jerome and the older saint to our right are particularly
powerful. For the rest, the interior of this church is more gorgeous
than tasteful; and the other works which it contains, including the
two Peruginos, and some tolerable monuments, are third rate. The
rotunda of the choir was designed by Leo Battista Alberti and erected at
the cost of the Marquis of Mantua, whose descendant, San Luigi
Gonzaga, had a special devotion to the miraculous picture.
From the
north transept, the cloisters are entered. Here, over the door, is the
Madonna del Sacco, an exceedingly beautiful fresco by Andrea del Sarto,
painted in 1525. St. Joseph, leaning upon the sack which gives the picture
its name, is reading aloud the Prophecies to the Mother and Child whom they
concern. In this cloister--which was built by Cronaca--is the monument of the
French knight slain at Campaldino in 1289 (_see_ chapter ii.), which should
be contrasted with the later monuments of condottieri in the Duomo. Here also
is the chapel of St. Luke, where the Academy of Artists, founded under
Cosimo I., used to meet.
A good view of the exterior of the rotunda
can be obtained from the Via Gino Capponi. At the corner of this street and
the Via del Mandorlo is the house which Andrea del Sarto bought for himself
and his Lucrezia, after his return from France, and here he died in
1531, "full of glory and of domestic sorrows." Lucrezia survived him
for nearly forty years, and died in 1570. Perhaps, if she had not
made herself so unpleasant to her husband's pupils and assistants,
good Giorgio Vasari--the youngest of them--might not have left us so dark
a picture of this beautiful Florentine.
The rather picturesque bit of
ruin in the Via degli Alfani, at the corner of the Via del Castellaccio, is
merely a part of an oratory in connection with Santa Maria degli Angioli,
which Brunelleschi commenced for Filippo Scolari, but which was abandoned.
_Santa Maria degli Angioli_ itself, a suppressed Camaldolese house, was of
old one of the most important convents in Florence. The famous poet,
Fra Guittone d'Arezzo, of whom Dante speaks disparagingly in
the _Commedia_ and in the _De Vulgari Eloquentia_, was instrumental in
its foundation in 1293. It was sacked in 1378 during the rising of
the Ciompi. This convent in the earlier portion of the fifteenth
century was a centre of Hellenic studies and humanistic culture, under
Father Ambrogio Traversari, who died at the close of the Council of
Florence. In the cloister there is still a powerful fresco by Andrea
del Castagno representing Christ on the Cross, with Madonna and
the Magdalene, the Baptist, St. Benedict and St. Romuald. The
Romuald especially, the founder of the order, is a fine life-like
figure.
The _Spedale di Santa Maria Nuova_ was originally founded by
Messer Folco Portinari, the father of the girl who may have been
Dante's "Giver of Blessing," in 1287. Folco died in 1289, and is buried
within the church, which contains one of Andrea della Robbia's Madonnas.
Over the portal is a terracotta Coronation of the Madonna by Bicci
di Lorenzo, erected in 1424. The two frescoes, representing scenes in
the history of the hospital, are of the early part of the
fifteenth century; the one on the right was painted in 1424 by Bicci di
Lorenzo. In the Via Bufalini, Ghiberti had his workshop; in what was once
his house is now the picture gallery of the hospital. Here is the
fresco of the Last Judgment, commenced by Fra Bartolommeo in 1499, before
he abandoned the world, and finished by Mariotto Albertinelli. Among
its contents are an Annunciation by Albertinelli, Madonnas by
Cosimo Rosselli and Rosso Fiorentino, and a terracotta Madonna
by Verrocchio. The two pictures ascribed to Angelico and Botticelli
are not authentic. But in some respects more interesting than
these Florentine works is the triptych by the Fleming, Hugo Van der
Goes, painted between 1470 and 1475 for Tommaso Portinari, Messer
Folco's descendant; in the centre is the "Adoration of the Shepherds,"
with deliciously quaint little Angels; in the side wings, Tommaso
Portinari with his two boys, his wife and their little girl, are guarded
by their patron saints. Tommaso Portinari was agent for the Medici
in Bruges; and, on the occasion of the wedding of Charles the Bold
of Burgundy with Margaret of York in 1468, he made a fine show riding
in the procession at the head of the Florentines.
[Illustration: THE
CLOISTER OF THE INNOCENTI]
A little more to the east are the church and
suppressed convent of Santa Maria Maddalena de' Pazzi. In the church, which
has a fine court designed by Giuliano da San Gallo, is a Coronation of the
Madonna by Cosimo Rosselli; in the chapter-house of the convent is a
Crucifixion by Perugino, painted in the closing years of the Quattrocento,
perhaps the grandest of all his frescoes. In Ruskin's chapter on
the _Superhuman Ideal_, in the second volume of _Modern Painters_,
he cites the background of this fresco (together with Benozzo Gozzoli's in
the Palazzo Riccardi) as one of the most perfect examples of those ideal
landscapes of the religious painters, in which Perugino is supreme: "In the
landscape of the fresco in Sta. Maria Maddalena at Florence there is more
variety than is usual with him: a gentle river winds round the bases of rocky
hills, a river like our own Wye or Tees in their loveliest reaches; level
meadows stretch away on its opposite side; mounds set with slender-stemmed
foliage occupy the nearer ground, and a small village with its simple spire
peeps from the forest at the bend of the valley."
Beyond is the church
of Sant' Ambrogio, once belonging to the convent of Benedictine nuns for whom
Fra Lippo Lippi painted his great Coronation of Madonna. The church is hardly
interesting at present, but contains an Assumption by Cosimo Rosselli, and,
in the chapel of the Blessed Sacrament, a marble tabernacle by Mino da
Fiesole and a fresco by Cosimo Rosselli painted in 1486, representing the
legend of a miraculous chalice with some fine Florentine portrait
heads, altogether above the usual level of Cosimo's work.
The Borgo la
Croce leads hence to the Porta alla Croce, in the very prosaic and modern
Piazza Beccaria. This Porta alla Croce, the eastern gate of Florence in the
third walls, was commenced by Arnolfo di Cambio in 1284; the frescoed Madonna
in the lunette is by one of the later followers of Ghirlandaio. Through this
gate, on October 6th 1308, Corso Donati fled from Florence, after his
desperate attempt to hold the Piazza di San Piero Maggiore against the forces
of the Signoria. Following the Via Aretina towards Rovezzano, we soon
reach the remains of the Badia di San Salvi, where he was slain by
his captors--as Dante makes his brother Forese darkly prophesy in
the twenty-fourth canto of the _Purgatorio_. Four year later, in
October 1312, the Emperor Henry VII. lay sick in the Abbey, while his
army ineffectually besieged Florence. Nothing remains to remind us of
that epoch, although the district is still called the Campo di Marte
or Campo di Arrigo. We know from Leonardo Bruni that Dante, although
he had urged the Emperor on to attack the city, did not join the
imperial army like many of his fellow exiles had done: "so much reverence
did he yet retain for his fatherland." In the old refectory of the
Abbey is Andrea del Sarto's Last Supper, one of his most admirable
frescoes, painted between 1525 and 1527, equally excellent in colour and
design. "I know not," writes Vasari, "what to say of this _Cenacolo_
that would not be too little, seeing it to be such that all who behold
it are struck with astonishment." When the siege was expected in 1529, and
the defenders of the city were destroying everything in the suburbs which
could give aid or cover to the enemy, a party of them broke down a wall in
the convent and found themselves face to face with this picture. Lost in
admiration, they built up a portion of what they had destroyed, in order that
this last triumph of Florentine painting might be secure from the hand of war. |
|
댓글 없음:
댓글 쓰기